Posts tagged 'Negative Rates'

Why life insurers haven’t escaped the spectre of negative rates

This guest post is from Camp Alphaville speaker Themis Themistocleous, who is head of the European Investment Office at UBS Wealth Management

_______ Read more

The Old Lady of Threadneedle Street blogs!

Welcome to Bank Underground, the official (and slightly subversive sounding?) Bank of England staff blog.

It’s gone live this Friday, with not one but two inaugural posts touching on topics as far ranging as the impact of driverless cars on the insurance industry to the somewhat wonkish debate over how the ELB (effective lower bound) might one day constrain monetary policy and inflation.

While the BoE isn’t the first central bank to publish staff analysis in blog form– the New York Fed’s staff have been blogging on Liberty Street Economics since 2012 — it is the first that intends to use the medium as a mechanism for self-scrutiny and internal challenge.

As Andy Haldane, the Bank’s chief economist and executive director of monetary analysis and statistics told FT Alphaville this fits with the Bank’s push to make itself more open and transparent. Read more

Of negative rates and reserve managers

Might have to pop this at the top, it’s a chart with lots of negative yield stuff on it after all:

Now, as we have said before… friends don’t let friends extrapolate too wildly from the IMF’s COFER data.  Read more

Why negative rates may inspire market consolidation

We had a hunch back in July 2012 that negative rates, as and when they would surely manifest, would create all sorts of perverse incentives for banks and capital owners.

Notably, our point was, that banks would prefer to lend money to monopoly-minded corporates focused on artificially constraining supply — rather than those focused on improving competition rather or pursuing capex policies. Failing that, a negative rate environment would otherwise create a plethora of zombie corporates propped up with cheap financing, producing output that isn’t necessarily valued much by anyone in the wider world. Read more

The return of goldsmith banking

The exciting thing about negative rates in the current context is that they make the fundamental ETF, MMF and repo-type structure that lies at the core of central banking much more obvious.

In a negative rate regime the “central bank ETF” essentially clips your rights to the underlying collateral that it holds on your behalf, often, beyond the arbitrage spread a primary dealer can secure. It’s easy for a regular ETF to enforce such a management fee because all its units are electronically registered. All costs, as a result, are distributed equally. If the managing fee is too great, meanwhile, customers would just go elsewhere. Read more

Of negative rates and golden retrievers

Yes, yes, we should just look away, Bill Gross wants your clicks. But…

It would be pretentious to say that I resembled Honey in any way, but nonetheless she was the puppy I chose. Honey turned out to be a little bit of a tramp, so maybe there’s the connection. Back in the freewheeling ‘80s when society had not even contemplated poop scooping and blue pick-up bags, Honey would roam the neighborhood, depositing wherever she pleased, but bringing things back home in return.

 Read more

Negative govvies: why would ya?

A question worth asking considering the rather large amount of them knocking about at the moment. According to JPM, the total universe of government bonds traded with a negative yield was $3.6tr last week or 16 per cent of the JPM Global Government Bond Index. It’s an answer in itself, really.

Anyway, here’s a list of those willing/ forced to buy those negative yielding government bonds from JPM’s Niko Panigirtzoglou: Read more

Negative rates and Gesell taxes: how low are we talking here?

It’s a brave new world, even if the idea behind the ever more deeply negative rates being tried out in Switzerland and Denmark isn’t that new at all. Silvio Gesell — Keynes‘ strange, unduly neglected prophet — got there quite a while ago via his eponymous tax. It’s an idea that gets dredged back up every now and then and we’re tempted to do so again here as it neatly frames any conversation about any constraint on how negative these negative rates can get. Read more

Behold the Euroglut

What ails Europe is not “secular stagnation” or “normalisation”, but rather the much more specific problem of a “Euroglut”.

So, at least, says George Saravelos at Deutsche Bank.

His argument relates to the idea that the global imbalances which were created by Europe’s massive current account surplus are becoming the defining variables which will drive a weaker euro, low long-end yields and exceptionally flat global yield curves, as well as ongoing inflows into “good” EM assets. Read more

Negative rates, in context

Peter Stella, former head of the Central Banking and Monetary and Foreign Exchange Operations Divisions at the International Monetary Fund, who now heads his own consulting company, is — as ever — on a mission to explain central bank actions for what they really are.

His latest focus area: the real story behind negative interest rates at the ECB.

Critical to understanding the purpose of these, he suggests, is the following chart:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  Read more

Well, what did you expect in a negative rate environment?

Gary Jenkins at LNG Capital brings us news on Wednesday that… yes, peripheral eurozone bond yields are or in some cases are just about to trade through US Treasuries.

But why should we be shocked about this?

Or as he puts it:

There has been a few headlines recently which suggested that we should be shocked that Spanish 10 year government bond yields now trade through treasuries and that the Italian equivalent is just a few basis points away. I think that these Eurozone countries should trade through treasuries. I think Portuguese bonds should do the same. Greece? Not so much… The fact is that since Mario Draghi started acting like a modern day central banker and the leading politicians looked into the abyss of what the default of a major European country like Spain might look like the yields on the so called ‘periphery’ European bonds have been converging with those of the core at a rapid rate.

 Read more

Goldman Sachs on coping with negative rates

There’s a good note from Goldman Sachs this week on the implications of negative rates at the ECB.

But given that many of the points echo much of the discussion already featured on FT Alphaville for years, we’ll cut straight to the interesting bits.

Goldman agree there isn’t anything conceptually special about negative rates because bond math works with negative numbers (as it’s focused on real returns). However, they add, there is a specific reason why negative rates might have qualitatively different macroeconomic implications, unless controls on cash were put in place with them: Read more

Rogoff on negative rates, paper currency and Bitcoin

Ken Rogoff wades into the negative rate debate this month, in a paper that discusses the costs and benefits of phasing out paper currency — a topic previously explored by Willem Buiter and Miles Kimball (and of course Satoshi Nakamoto).

Among his observations is the somewhat provocative point (at least judging by the replies on Twitter) that…

Paying a negative interest rate on currency, or on electronic reserves at the central bank, may seem barbaric to some. But it is arguably no more barbaric than inflation, which similarly reduces the real purchasing power of currency.

Meaning that a good bout of inflation could be just as good as a negative rate regime. Read more

Denmark: don’t be so negative

Look, no minus signs.

Which means an experiment has ended in Denmark, for now. The CD rate rose 0.15 per cent on Thursday.

From the central bank…  Read more

Constructing negativity and the ECB

We wonder if, after a brief blaze of real scrutiny, people have started to look past the imposition of a negative deposit rate by the ECB in favour of the more seductive and mysterious ECB QE and how it might be constructed. And we wonder if that is something of a mistake.

How a move to negative is constructed will, of course, have much to do with what it is intended to achieve — a weaker euro at last check — but we also can’t help but think it would be cool to make sure it won’t cause too much harm either. Herein lies a plan. Read more

Draghi on the edge of deflation

The Credit Suisse European economics team are growing concerned about Mario Draghi’s disinflation problem:

 Read more

ECB is technically ready for negative rates

The Great Draghini has spoken on negative rates, collateral and on volatility:

DRAGHI – HAD AMPLE DISCUSSION OF NONSTANDARD MEASURES
DRAGHI – DISCUSSED NEGATIVE DEPOSIT FACILITY
DRAGHI – TECHNICALLY READY FOR NEGATIVE DEPOSIT RATES, BUT NO REASON TO ACT RIGHT NOW

 Read more

Game of negative rates

From Morgan Stanley’s combined banks/economics/credit/rates research team on Tuesday:

 Read more

On crossing the ECB interest-rate streams

If the ECB were to introduce negative rates, FT Alphaville has mostly focused on the idea that the it would do so primarily in its deposit rate. That’s where market chatter has largely concentrated.

But as someone wiser than us noted in an emailed comment, that would be almost entirely redundant. Read more

What is the opposite of helicopter money?

This is a short follow-up to Monday’s negative rate confusion and prepay-tax option post.

In it we argued two very simple points:

1) Negative rates might very well cause Eonia to go up because they are in fact liquidity contractionary.

2) Negative rates are contractionary because they encourage all of the following: banknote hoarding instead of excess reserves, capital flight (which manifests by means of a depreciating exchange rate which can impact non-depository asset valuations), the prepayment of private tax liabilities, the unwinding of LTROs/MROs, the resale of ECB held bond assets back into the market.

 Read more

99 Draghi trial balloons [updated]

(With some header credit due to Mark Dow)

He came, he cut, he stuck a load of fingers in the air…

The tl;dr version of May’s Draghi presser involved the ECB chief mentioning a heap of possible actions — from getting the “dead” ABS market going to help SMEs, through to negative interest rates, while giving a little bit of forward guidance on policy — but without committing to anything concrete. Read more

Cash-for-gold at negative rates

The conspiracy channels continue to make a big deal about the backwardation of gold — which is a situation in which gold prices for today are higher than for tomorrow. The thinking is that this must indicate rampant demand for physical gold.

In reality, since gold is a highly financialised commodity, the backwardation signal doesn’t actually indicate the bullishness they imply it does. Rather, it suggests something entirely different: that interest rates in conventional money markets are turning increasingly negative. Read more

The negative rate bluff

Negative rates, as we’ve discussed before, are a funny thing.

On the one hand they can send an immensely powerful message. On the other hand they have the power to seriously and dangerously disrupt core economic mechanisms by magnifying the physical hoarding incentive — this helps to create a negative feedback loop that ultimately crowds out capital and leads to voluntary capital destruction. Read more

A negative spin to crude’s mysterious slide

People are still scratching their heads over what possibly sparked crude oil’s sell-off in the middle the US trading day on Monday.

Explanations in contention include: fat fingers, SPR talk and general illiquidity due to the Jewish New Year. Read more

Negative rates as a precursor to the death of banking

FT Alphaville has presented its case on negative rates and zero deposit rates here and here (amongst other places).

What we believe is that rather than stimulating the lending market — and the economy along with it — such a rate policy could have a disastrous impact on collateral markets and money market funds, not to mention the net interest income of lending institutions. All of which could unleash a protracted deflationary spiral. Read more

The cost of zero rates, broker edition

The FT’s Greg Meyer had a great piece out last week about the negative impact micro yields are having on the broker sector.

For a long time, the broker-dealer model has depended on the ability to reinvest customer funds to earn additional revenue. But in a zero-yield world that source of revenue is becoming constricted. Read more

What next for European MMFs?

Fee waivers and duration extension, according to Fitch’s Fund & Asset Manager rating group.

They’re talking, of course, about how European money market funds will react to the ECB’s decision to cut its deposit rate to zero, a fact which should soon push the Euro overnight index average (Eonia) to historical lows of between -15 and +15 bps, putting MMF yields at risk of negativity. Read more

Taux négatifs

The latest sovereign to borrow at negative yields — France.

 Read more

Negativity at the door, euro money market fund edition

The cut in the deposit facility rate to zero will almost certainly move cash bids in short-dated instruments into negative territory, and so we have taken the step to restrict subscriptions and switches in to the Funds in order to protect existing shareholders from yield dilution…

That’s JPMorgan, explaining why it’s closed five European liquidity-themed funds to new investors, following Thursday’s rate cuts by the ECB. “We wish to restrict growth in assets at this time,” etc. Read more

Well, we were asking about ECB negative rates…

(That’s Lisa, at Thursday’s European Central Bank press conference) Read more