Arguably, none of the below matters now.
That’s the prime effect of the German constitutional court turning to the European Court of Justice for a ruling on whether the ECB’s sovereign bond-buying programme is a “structurally significant transgression of powers” under European treaty law.
Big words. But the backing of the Bundesverfassungsgericht judges (pictured right) for that view gets rendered into just another opinion, pending the ECJ’s decision. And the arc of the ECJ’s justice is long, turgidly written, but ultimately quite friendly to pieces of bailout architecture that have an odd relationship to the treaties — as in past musings on the ESM.
But the really interesting thing is that regardless, the OMT’s purpose apparently remains almost completely lost on the court. Read more
Courtesy of the Bundesbank (h/t Dario Perkins):
In a nutshell, the paper concludes that current account adjustment is significantly hampered in countries that are members of a monetary union. This holds particularly in comparison with floating exchange rate regimes owing to the lower level of exchange rate flexibility. Furthermore, the persistence of current account balances in member countries of a monetary union is also more pronounced than in fixed-rate regimes due to less flexible interest rates as a result of the single monetary policy.
Something funny happened to the eurozone over summer. Things… began to look better.
Of course, there are plenty of difficulties lying in wait. As the FT’s Peter Spiegel and Alex Barker write, once a new German government is in place after this weekend’s election, fraught negotiations about Greece, Portugal, Ireland and the banking union will quickly return to the fore. Read more
We thought the following from TD Securities’ Richard Gilhooly on Tuesday was a rather insightful way of looking at the whole BoJ effect (our emphasis):
While it remains a contentious point and as yet unproven, Japan’s devaluation and soaring Nikkei vs slumping DAX or Bovespa has all the hallmarks of a competitive devaluation. While competing factions debate the Monetary expansion/QQE, versus beggar-thy-neighbour interpretation, one positive aspect of the Japanese Yen collapse and fear of exported deflation has been collapsing commodity prices with weak growth in export countries (China, Germany, S Korea) and a stronger USD helping a supply story (crude inventories at 22yr highs) and weak demand send commodities into a bear market.
Depressing eurozone and German prints below. The eurozone composite was bleakly steady at 46.5 while the German comp hit 48.8 from 50.6 in March — its worst level in six months. The only real good news is that this might increase the chances of an ECB refi cut in the near future.
But since France came out first…. Read more
William Porter at Credit Suisse has been mulling the market’s muted reaction to the Italian elections. Increased stress is no longer finding its way into widening spreads, thanks to the Draghi “put”.
This credit strategist is concerned. A dampened signaling mechanism increases the risk of something going badly wrong — a market crash, even. Read more
Cyprus is almost over the first hurdle — the pro-bailout Nicos Anastasiades handily won the first round of the island’s presidential elections last week. As the FT notes, he will face Stavros Malas, the Akel (Cyprus communist) party candidate, who won 27 per cent, in the run-off on February 24 and it’s pretty likely Anastasiades will come out on top.
What is less likely, is that there will be a sudden move towards that €17bn-ish international bailout Cyprus has hankering for. It’s not as if there has been unseemly speed so far: Read more
The eurozone’s largest economy has defied the crisis better than most expected, yet it couldn’t maintain growth in the final quarter of last year, shrinking by an estimated 0.6 per cent. That compares to France’s 0.3 per cent and Spain’s 0.7 per cent respective falls. But given that usually Germany is the region’s engine of growth, the key question is how long this weakness might last.
Fortunately it seems that the recovery might be brisk. Read more
You know what doesn’t often conjure images of economic happiness? The 1970s, that’s what. And the argument coming from some quarters right now is that Europe, or at least its periphery, is heading back into such a period of stagnation and chronic inflation with unemployment leading the way. Read more
From a report by Germany’s spy agency in early November arguing that the main beneficiaries of aid to Cypriot banks would be rich Russians who have invested illegal money there, through to a very public bailout veto threat. All in just two months! Speedy work indeed by Germany’s opposition.
From Eurointelligence on Wednesday:
Suddeutsche Zeitung is reporting this morning that the SPD [Social Democratic Party] is considering blocking a Cyprus deal on the grounds that it won’t support tax dumping and money laundering.
As expected, the eurozone economy shrunk in the third quarter. But, fortunately, not by quite as much as expected.
Thursday’s data did, however, confirm that the debt crisis in southern Europe is hitting the ‘core’ economies in northern Europe, and analysts seem in agreement that it’s going to get significantly worse. Read more
Another day, and another confirmation that the eurozone economy is struggling to gain traction. And it’s not just the small peripheral economies that are seeing factory activity slowing.
Markit’s Eurozone Manufacturing Purchasing Managers’ Index (PMI) fell to 45.4 in October from September’s 46.1. The October figure was just up from an earlier reported flash reading of 45.3. The index has been below the 50 mark that divides growth from contraction since August 2011.
It’s Eurozone flash PMI time again. It’s a sad time. From Markit:
The Eurozone sank further into decline at the start of the fourth quarter, with the combined output of the manufacturing and service sectors dropping at the fastest rate since June 2009.
Germany’s IFO survey didn’t help much either.
Or peripheral pain in terms of growth/shrinkage in compensation per employee. It offers a striking illustration of why both Greeks and Germans have reason to feel peeved… Read more
Germany wants to audit its gold held abroad. Paranoia or sensible book keeping? To be fair, there’s quite a bit of it (feel free to read that any way you choose). From the Spiegel:
Germany has the second largest gold reserves in the world, nearly 3400 tons. Supposedly, anyway. Because stocks have never been checked for authenticity and weight. Now, the Federal Court has asked the Bundesbank to examine the gold reserves abroad regularly.
“Immobilie porn”, suggests Google Translate but we’re open to correction.
Either way, this piece from the FT on Tuesday makes for good reading. It suggests there may be a bubble building in the German property market with Berlin in particular looking peaky, although that must be caveated with the relatively sedate nature of the market previously. Read more
Non-german speakers should be able to guess the meaning, especially if we add the words ‘Greece’ and ‘Wolfgang Schaeuble’ by way of context.
Yes, Staatsbankrott = ‘state bankruptcy.’
Not that it’s going to happen in the case of Greece, of course — at least not according to the German finance minister. Read more
Citi are pushing that fateful day back:
We have held the view, since May 2012, that a Greek exit from the euro area (“Grexit”) in the next 12 to 18 months is a high-probability event (90%) which we assume, for the sake of argument, would happen on January 1 2013. We are now cutting the probability of Grexit over the next 12-18 months to 60% and judge that this event will probably happen later than we previously thought, most likely in 1H 2014.
A cynic might suggest they were getting the jitters as deadline approached but lets hear them out (our emphasis). Read more
Here’s the running order for Angela Merkel’s
last? visit to Athens. Graphic courtesy of Bild.
Look, look: it’s Target2 imbalances… rebalancing… slightly.
What’s the justification for creating a three-ring security circus in the Greek capital, a general strike and quite possibly a major riot? Read more
If you think Germany’s response to the crisis has been less than lightning swift so far…
JP Morgan’s Alex White argues that the German policy motor may be about to properly slow down, and with it the response to the eurozone crisis which usually moves at Germany’s speed: Read more
Germany business sentiment fell again in September, from 102.3 to 101.4, marking its fifth succesive month of contraction. The roughly 7,000 companies surveyed by the Ifo institute were also increasingly pessimistic about their futures… which doesn’t bode well for everyone else’s.
Forecasts had been for a slight increase in the index but, with typically sharp turnaround speed, our inboxes now expect a recession. Capital Economics said the expectations index in particular, down from 94.2 to 93.2, indicates an annual fall in GDP of nearly 1 per cent: Read more
Poor Jens Weidmann.
After weeks of macro-economic sniping following his isolation at the European Central Bank over its new bond-buying policy, Jens Weidmann on Tuesday resorted to Goethe’s Faust to make his point. The classic play highlighted, he argued, “the core problem of today’s paper money-based monetary policy” and the “potentially dangerous correlation of paper money creation, state financing and inflation”. Read more
Would you like three long, dense paragraphs of German legal rumination on a idea that’s already DOA? That’d be the ESM funding itself through European Central Bank liquidity.
Of course you would (and if not, you can always skip to the analysis below): Read more
German finance minister Wolfgang Schaeuble was addressing the Bundestag on Tuesday…
BFW 09/11 08:28 Schaeuble Says Greece Has Undertaken ‘Impressive’ Steps
BFW 09/11 08:26 Schaeuble Says ECB’s Independence Must Be Defended, Respected
BFW 09/11 08:18 Schaeuble Says Euro Crisis ‘Not Over,’ Be Around for Months
BN 09/11 09:08 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS GERMANY AGAINST `DEBT UNION, EURO BONDS’
BN 09/11 09:07 *SCHAEUBLE: GERMANY SHOWS GROWTH, CONSOLIDATION NO CONTRADICTION
BN 09/11 09:05 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS GERMANY UNLIKELY TO BEAT 1.6% GROWTH 2013
BN 09/11 09:04 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS GERMANY TO AT LEAST MEET 2012 BORROWING TARGET
BN 09/11 08:36 *SCHAEUBLE: GERMANY WILL EXCEED DEBT BRAKE REQUIREMENTS BY FAR
BN 09/11 08:35 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS GERMANY DETERMINED TO CUT NEW BORROWING
BN 09/11 08:33 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS GERMAN 2012 0.7% GROWTH FORECAST WELL SUPPORTED
BN 09/11 08:31 *SCHAEUBLE: FUTURE ESM BANK RECAPS MUST BE REQUESTED BY STATES
BN 09/11 08:31 *SCHAEUBLE: UNREALISTIC TO HAVE SUPERVISION OF 6,000 BANKS SOON
BN 09/11 08:26 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS EUROPE HAS LEARNED FROM ITS CRISIS
BN 09/11 08:25 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS STABILITY AND GROWTH PACT HAS `MORE TEETH’ NOW
BN 09/11 08:25 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS `WE’RE ON THE RIGHT TRACK’ IN THE EURO REGION
BN 09/11 08:25 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS ITALY, SPAIN HAVE MADE CONSIDERABLE PROGRESS
BN 09/11 08:24 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS GREECE PROGRAM CONDITIONS CAN’T BE RENEGOTIATED
BN 09/11 08:24 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS GREECE MUST MEET ALL PROGRAM CONDITIONS
BN 09/11 08:24 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS PORTUGAL FIGURES SHOW REFORMS TAKING HOLD
BN 09/11 08:23 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS GERMAN PARLIAMENT MUST BACK NEW AID PROGRAMS
BN 09/11 08:21 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS ECB’S INDEPENDENCE MUST BE DEFENDED, RESPECTED
BN 09/11 08:21 *SCHAEUBLE: SHARED LIABILITY, PRINTING PRESS WON’T SOLVE WOES
BN 09/11 08:21 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS THERE WON’T BE ONE BIG BANG TO SOLVE CRISIS
BN 09/11 08:20 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS GERMANY UNLIKELY TO SEE STRONG UNEMPLOYEMNT GAIN
BN 09/11 08:17 *SCHAEUBLE: GERMANY BETTER ADJUSTED TO GLOBALIZATION THAN OTHERS
BN 09/11 08:16 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS GERMANY HAS BECOME MORE RESILIENT TO SHOCKS
BN 09/11 08:14 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS GERMAN ECONOMY’S EXPANSION IS SLOWING
BN 09/11 08:13 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS EURO CRISIS `NOT OVER,’ BE AROUND FOR MONTHS
BN 09/11 08:12 *GERMAN FINANCE MINISTER SCHAEUBLE SPEAKING IN GERMAN PARLIAMENT
BN 09/11 08:12 *SCHAEUBLE SAYS ECONOMIC SITUATION OVERSHADOWED BY EURO CRISIS Read more
From Reuters earlier on Tuesday:
Germany’s constitutional court said on Tuesday it would not postpone its long-awaited ruling on the legality of the euro zone’s bailout fund despite a new legal challenge by a eurosceptic lawmaker. Read more
There are two fairly important bits to this story in Der Spiegel.
One, that Merkel wants to avoid a Grexit for the time being and two, that the upcoming Troika report might be massaged to make that a reality. Read more
Let’s start on a positive note on the volley of Markit PMI released Monday.
Spain’s PMI rose during August to 44, versus 42.3 in July… Read more