Markets Live chat transcript for the chat ending at 11:33 on 17 May 2011. Participants in this chat were: bryce.elder Tony Tassell
http://www.toptenz.net/top-10-deadliest-prisons-world.php
Rikers Island, New York – Stabbings, beatings and brutal treatment from prison guards characterize this American prison. Filled primarily with offenders who are visible minorities, jailed on drug offenses, the prison is a hotbed of violence and aggression. In 2007, prisoner Charles Afflic was beaten senseless with a billy club by a prison official, who hit him repeatedly from behind: his injuries were so severe they necessitated brain surgery. 6 inmates committed suicide, hanging themselves with bedsheets in their cells, during the first six months of 2003 alone. Rikers has a reputation for its cruel treatment of mentally ill prisoners, who often turn to suicide in lieu of treatment and understanding.
On the other hand, the Bank insists that there is a compelling case for inflation falling back towards target from 2012. The VAT rises of the past two years have pushed up price growth in 2010 and 2011, while the global commodity price rally in the second half of 2010 has also led to higher goods prices in the UK. By 2012, the effect of VAT on prices will have dropped out of the annual rate of inflation, and there are now early signs of some stabilisation in global commodity markets.
The major surprise in the CPI numbers came from air transport, where prices increased by 29.0% m/m. As a result, travel services as a whole showed m/m inflation of 5.2%, compared to our forecast of 0.5%, contributing an additional 0.3pp to m/m inflation overall. Air fares are one of the most volatile components of the CPI (despite being included in the core measure), and the higher-than-expected increase in prices is likely to have been driven largely by the impact of the timing of Easter. The other area where prices increased significantly was alcoholic beverages and tobacco, where duty increases announced at the budget pushed prices up by 5.3% m/m. However, this was in line with our forecast.
We will publish an updated inflation forecast shortly. Our initial impression is that the upside surprise in today’s numbers is likely to be largely unwound in May, and as a result we would not anticipate significant changes to our forecast.
distortion but this still leaves the CPIY measure (ie, stripping out those indirect tax
effects) a full percentage point above the 2% target. Whilst this overshoot is to a
large degree simply a reflection of the energy price shock, the clearer evidence of
early spill-overs into areas such as transportation will be viewed by some as a sign
that second-round effects are materialising. Equally, given the continuing absence
of inflationary wage settlements, this energy-related shock will exert an even more
painful squeeze on consumer demand in more discretionary areas. Whatever your
inclination on this medium-term inflation debate, April’s data are miserable.
By Catherine Belton in Moscow and Sylvia Pfeifer in London
Published: May 17 2011 08:59 | Last updated: May 17 2011 09:17
BP‘s bid for a strategic alliance with Rosneft, the Russian state oil champion, collapsed on Tuesday after the UK oil group failed to reach agreement to salvage its $16bn share swap before a midnight deadline expired.
Rosneft was not willing to extend the deadline further, a person close to the state company said, after talks failed over a deal to buy out BP’s partners in TNK-BP, its existing Russian joint venture. A person familiar with the matter said Rosneft would now seek new partners for the Arctic exploration deal it had proposed for the alliance with BP.
between BP and AAR in TNK-BP, but we would point out that this has survived considerable
strain in the past.
aftermath of the Macondo accident, the apparent failure of the deal may create something of
a hole in the BP story that management may feel the need to address. It is not clear at this
time what any replacement might be.
BP management, whose reputation has been tarnished by these recent developments, we
believe investors will be pleased that the controversial share swap element of the deal will not
take place and that recent uncertainty appears (almost) over
EPS of the share swap in their forecasts (we did not do so). If the share swap is finished, as
now seems likely, this may force these analysts and inventors to upgrade their EPS forecasts.
introduce a substantial, stable shareholder to create a degree of protection against possible
takeover. If the share swap does not go ahead, this negative for the share price is eliminated.
January. Assuming that the Rosneft deal is now unlikely to go ahead, we regard this as a
considerable over-reaction and would expect today’s news to generate improved relative
performance in the coming days.
Vodafone repeating the weak results of KPN (Buy) in particular due to its
mis-bundled price plans (or should that be mis-priced bundles, or both?). There
are no obvious signs of Vodafone suffering similar issues. Data revenues are up
26.4% in the year. Of the other strategic areas, emerging markets are up 11.8%,
fixed up 5.2% and European enterprise up 0.5%.
n Within the numbers, much focus is always attributed to the organic revenue
progression of the major reporting countries. For Q4, the organic service revenue
growth metrics came in as follows: Germany +0.8% (consensus -0.1%); Italy
-2.1% (consensus -2.2%); Spain -6.9% (consensus -7%); UK +4.7% (consensus
+6.5%); and India +16.2% (consensus +16%).
addressing the global enterprise market, joint purchasing using combined buying
power and technology standardisation. There is no further clarity in the release on
looming dividend distributions from VZW to Vodafone which have suffered a
6-year hiatus (Vodafone only receiving a sum to notionally cover the taxation
implications of its holding), but we suspect this will come in due course.
n Our Buy recommendation and DCF-based TP of 230p remain. Vodafone is our
top pick of the sector, set to benefit, we believe, from increasing data
monetisation, particularly in the near term, through the democratisation of
smartphones. The key risk to this stance revolves around the potential for voice
and SMS declines to override the data growth, or the need to ramp up investment
more than anticipated to cope with increasing data demand.
DETAILS – Vodafone reported FY revenues/EBITDA/EPS of £45.9bn / £14.7bn and 16.44p respectively vs consensus of £44.5bn/£14.7bn and 16.35p. Free cash flow of £7.05bn comfortably beat our estimate of £6.3bn and consensus of £6.7bn. However, ‘11/12 FCF guidance of £6.0-6.5bn is well below the market estimate of £7.2bn, but more in line with our £6bn forecast.
VALUATION AND RECOMMENDATION – We will review our 169p price target for FY results, but retain our reduce recommendation.
£11.38 bn (organic service revenue growth of 2.5% yoy) were 3.7% ahead
of company gathered consensus, driven by ongoing strength in emerging
markets (both India and Vodacom beat our expectations), while Europe
was slightly weak (service revenue growth -0.8% yoy, with Spain and Italy
slightly weaker than expected). FY2011 EBITDA of £14.70 bn and adjusted
operating profit of £11.82 bn are exactly in line with consensus. Adjusted
EPS of 16.75p was 2.5% ahead of consensus, while FCF of £7.05 bn was 6%
above consensus owing to very strong working capital inflows.
consensus of £11.6 bn; FCF is expected to be between £6.0-6.5 bn vs.
consensus of £7.0 bn. The reduction yoy in AOP and FCF principally
reflects the divestments of SFR and China Mobile, which will contribute
c.£0.5 bn / £0.3 bn to AOP and FCF respectively in FY2012. Weaker FCF
guidance also reflects the stronger than expected working capital inflows in
FY2011, which are not expected to be repeated. Mid-term guidance for 1%-
4% organic revenue growth and stabilizing EBITDA margins across the
period was also reiterated. The mid-term FCF target of £6.0-7.0 bn has been
reduced by £0.5 bn owing to SFR/China Mobile.
After a weak reporting season from European operators, Vodafone’s solid
results and conservative guidance are likely to be viewed positively.
Although FY2012 guidance is slightly light of consensus, we note that
Vodafone has consistently exceeded its guidance for the last two years. We
also expect management to talk down SMS/voice cannibalization risks at
the analysts’ meeting, noting that its bundling strategy is proving effective.
We expect a modest relief rally in the stock today post recent
underperformance. We put our estimates and price target under review.
Aviva has reported life and pensions new business of £7,770m, 1.5% below our
forecast and 15% below Q110. However the margin of 2.5% is higher than our
FY11 forecast of 2.3%. UK sales were 6% below our forecast due to 15% lower
than expected annuities and a 34% fall in bond sales. This was largely offset by 9%
better than expected sales in Europe, driven by a smaller than expected decline in
Italy and 13% growth in Ireland rather than a 10% forecast decline.
Non-life premium growth of 9% is ahead of our full year forecast of 5%, and the
Q111 combined ratio of 97% is in line with full year guidance and our estimates
despite inclement UK weather in Q1. Reserve releases have fallen, UK personal
motor rates have risen 24% and HSBC have renewed their distribution agreement
for another 5 years, suggesting a good Q1 for the GI unit overall.
Q1 reported EV of 576p looks in line with the expected level for this time of year
(FY10 542p) and on track for our full year forecast. The outlook comments are
positive, particularly for general insurance, and the financial targets are reiterated.
IGD surplus fell from £3.8bn to £3.5bn.
The stock offers value on earnings (IFRS PER 9x, sector 12x, EEV PER 6x, sector
7x), but EPS dilution remains a risk until the group completes its disposals.
Price/EV 80% (sector 86%) and a yield of 6.2% (sector 4.8%) also suggest value.
We remain Neutral, however, as the next expected newsflow is further dilutive
disposals.
most important development in our view. Remember, a key part of
our Overweight rating is a view that management has taken action in
recent years that have left its non-life business in good shape, and that
non-life would be a source of earnings upgrades for the stock – see our
recent note on the FSA returns for detail (link to the right). We believe
that this theme is starting to play out now.
to 102% versus 1Q10. In our view this is a very strong result for a
winter quarter, particularly given the statement that 1Q11 contained
“lower prior year reserve releases” – i.e. the quality improved YoY also.
• First sensitivity: if we assume that the rest of the year is exactly the
same as that experienced in 2011 the overall underwriting result should
come in at around £393mn compared to £263mn in 2010 and our current
forecast (pre-today) of c.£400mn.
normal weather for 2Q10 and 3Q10. If we normalized also 4Q10 then the
underwriting result could come in at around £433mn, higher than our
current forecast. Against this, reserve releases could be running at a
lower level than that experienced in 2010, which will provide some
offset.
• In combined ratio terms, the above we think translates into a full year
in the range of 96% versus the target of 97%. Aviva writes about £10bn
of non-life premiums, so each 1pp on the combined ratio is worth about
£75mn after tax, or 3.5p per share EPS.
they have started see some signs of commercial lines hardening, but that
the next 3 months would be key. This could be an additional positive and
is not something in our numbers currently.
We remain relatively cautious on markets in the
short-term and continue to favour defensive stocks
given: 1) current outperformance is relatively modest; 2)
seasonality trends; 3) defensives remain under-owned;
4) macro newsflow likely to weigh on risk appetite.
Long-term growth expectations for defensives at
record low versus cyclicals
In addition to these tactical considerations, there are two
other factors that may make defensives appealing to
longer-term investors. First, long-term EPS growth
expectations for defensives are at a record low relative
to cyclicals. Second, defensives also trade at long-term
valuation lows versus cyclicals on a variety of valuation
metrics.
What would make us turn more optimistic
Key macro catalysts to make us turn more positive on
markets and cyclicals again include: 1) a renewed
upturn in economic newsflow; 2) evidence that EM
inflation is peaking; 3) navigating the end of QE2 without
undue volatility.
It is not too late to add some exposure to
Pharmaceuticals. Post poor long-term performance the
sector offers good value, ownership levels are below
recent history, earnings expectations are at historically
low levels and any USD strength associated with the
end of QE2 should offer support.
Too early to bottom-fish in commodities
To fund our upgrade of Pharmaceuticals we reduce our
weighting in Energy. We like the commodity space from
a structural standpoint but believe it is too early to
bottom fish just now.
■
Earnings momentum negative – commodities down, cost pressures up.
Earnings trends -10y show that consensus earnings have consistently
lagged commodity and share prices by 3-6 months and downgrades have
tended to call a bottom to performance. Recent trends suggest an earnings
trough in June/July and improved relative performance from Q311.
■
Lagging indicator: YTD the sector spot PE has remained around 7.5x
showing the stocks are at least efficient in pricing in commodity movements.
Our focus remains on fundamentals; in H2 we expect rebounding IP
momentum and improved risk appetite to underpin metal prices and drive a
re-rating of the sector. Base metals have underperformed bulks significantly
YTD, we would expect some of this to reverse in H2 as visibility improves.
Our strategists expect ongoing appreciation of the A$ and ZAR, but
predicated on ongoing strength in the commodity cycle. To see the multi
year 20%+ pa inflation seen 2005-08 would require oil over $160/t in 2013
and A$/ZAR/Peso 20% stronger from here. Possible but unlikely without a
significant step up in commodity prices.
■
Stock picks: Copper (ANTO, KAZ) and platinum (LMI, AQP) screen with
the greatest downgrade risk. RIO remains top pick with cheap spot valuation,
our bullish outlook on iron ore in 2011/12 and upside potential from balance
sheet re-gearing. As confidence/visibility improves we would recommend
adding to core large cap names to gain greater exposure from more
leveraged/base metal exposed names.
appreciation in underlying commodities
The underlying cost base for many of the mining companies have direct linkage to
commodity prices themselves given the consumption of steel, grinding media, energy etc.
The rise in steel prices and the oil prices can be taken as good proxies for rising material
and energy costs.2005-08 witnessed 20%+ annual cost inflation each year. 2004-2008 the oil price more
than doubled from an average of $41 in 2004 to $100 in 2008. To see similar levels of
energy inflation the oil price would need to nearly double from below $80 in 2010 to close
to $160 in 2013.
On early morning conference calls, Mr. Kengeter has told senior bankers that he was done with their complaints about pay. “You just don’t get it,” he told thousands of bankers on more than one recent call, according to bankers who were on the call.
While we see limited risk of a significant miss for Invensys’ FY2011 results (due on 19
May) we now perceive emerging headwinds for Invensys Rail division (40% of Group
EBIT) as we progress into 2012-13.
(1) Failure to secure the London Underground SSR contract (worth c.GBP400m); (2)
Invensys Rail’s ability to deliver organic sales growth now relies on the tender for the
Saudi Mecca-Medina high speed line (worth c.GBP400m). Even if Invensys were to
win the contract, press reports suggest that pricing could be under pressure; (3)
Invensys holds three Network Rail ‘Type A’ regional signalling contracts (worth
c.GBP220m); these agreements originally ran through to 2011, with the option of an
extension out to 2016. With renegotiations taking place at a time when government
budgets are at their most distressed, the margins attached to future Type A work
could well prove to be lower than those achieved previously.
In the absence of significant contract opportunities for (particularly the UK) business,
we expect organic growth to turn negative at Invensys Rail from H2 2012e onwards.
We cut our FY2013 organic sales growth forecast for Invensys Rail to -3% from 3%.
We reduce our FY2013 SOP-based price target to reflect the changes to our forecasts
for Invensys Rail operating performance. The group trades on FY2013e EV/EBITA of
9.0x vs. the sector on 8.8x. We downgrade the stock to Neutral. We see better
opportunities elsewhere in the sector, Cookson (+, TP 800p) and IMI (+, TP 1220p).
expectations, so we expect the focus to be on detail as to why the
change of management was required and even more importantly
what will change, why and how under the new CEO.
broadly in line with consensus expectations and that performance was on
track. However, the company also announced the surprise resignation of
CEO Ulf Henriksson and the appointment of Wayne Edmunds, previously
CFO, as his successor. If results are in line therefore, we believe this will
be the key focus of the day.
Edmunds some indication as to what will change under his leadership and
why.
market will, we believe, be looking for reassurance of the go-to-market
strategy for Rail and IOM in particular.
• We expect little need for a major ‘kitchen sink’ to address any issues,
although we believe that Rail may need some capacity adjustment work in
the UK in the medium term as a result of the loss of the SSR contract.
• We forecast FY11 sales of GBP 2.44bn, +8.9% y-o-y and in line with
consensus expectations. We forecast operating profit before exceptional
items of GBP 259m (vs GBP 248m), in line with consensus expectations of
GBP 261m.
Invensys is potentially at risk if the stock materially underperforms on the
day.
• We maintain our Neutral recommendation and our share price target of
345p. The latter is based on our EVA® methodology applying a long-term
sustainable growth rate of 4%, an incremental ROIC of 26.3% and a pre-tax
WACC of 12.5%
in its smartcard business, with a suggested valuation (for 100%) of c€1bn. This
would clearly go some way to easing financing concerns on a bid for De La Rue. It
would also leave Oberthur a significantly smaller business and given a stated aim
to grow its banknote business (La Tribune, April 11), another bid for De La Rue is
quite possible in our view. The 6 month period in which Oberthur is restricted from
bidding for De La Rue ends on 24 July.
Whilst we would have expected a resolution on the India contract by now, the lack
of announcement on it suggests there has been no further news. We continue to
assume it is not retained in our forecasts. For the results, we are looking for
revenue of £471m (FY10: £561m), PBT of £29m (£104m) and EPS of 21p (76p).
With c5 months in the job, we would expect a detailed strategy review from the
new CEO, Tim Cobbold. We would expect a focus on self-help measures although
we believe the low hanging fruit was achieved under the Quinn management team.
Whilst stock remains fully valued and recovery takes time, we recognise increasing
probability of a bid. Our revised PT is based on 50% probability of a bid at £10.30
(we believe company looking for bid over £10 and Oberthur’s actions suggest it
would pay a strategic price), and 50% of our fair value of 565p. We upgrade our
rating to Neutral (from Sell).
attack by approximately 800 criminal intruders who illegally entered the North
Mara mine site and attempted to remove ore from the run of mine (ROM) pad.
criminal intruders armed with machetes, rocks and hammers.
wounds, resulting in seven intruder fatalities and twelve injuries.
have been deployed to the area. African Barrick Gold has also initiated an
internal company investigation. There have been no material impacts to the
operation or production.
regrets any loss of life or injury on or near its mine sites. The company will
continue to support the government and the community in their efforts to
improve law and order and security in the North Mara region.
SuperGroup (Buy): Talking of the weather, we have to always think of super SuperGroup in that context now, after last week’s embarrassing revelation that it didn’t have enough T-shirts and sandals to sell last month when the sun was shining. Of course, ever since then the weather has been more iffy, but we keep on getting emails from their Marketing department extolling the virtues of the new range and trumpeting the arrival of summer…And, as if to prove that if you can’t kick a man when he’s down when can you kick him etc, we spotted an item on the Retail Week website yesterday by their highly regarded Store Design Editor criticising the inflexibility of the latest expensive Superdry store design (”there is more to a winning brand than a good shopfit. Once in place it has to be capable of being updated”) and calling for them to move the concept on! Rumour has it that CEO Julian Dunkerton has been seen whirling around SuperGroup HQ in sunny Cheltenham crying “Infamy, infamy, they’ve all got it in for me…”.
Concerning Greece, euro area finance ministers evidently had a controversial and informal discussion. Eurogroup chair Juncker said that “if all the conditions [related to a quicker pace of asset sales and deeper spending cuts] were met, then we can discuss the question of ‘re-profiling’” (i.e. a ‘soft’, voluntary rescheduling of interest payments and/or maturity profiles). However, French FM Lagarde commented, “Restructuring, re-profiling: off the table”, while there were no briefings by German officials. Dutch FM de Jager commented that ministers had discussed “all kinds of topics, including restructuring, but in public we are very reluctant about discussing restructuring and debating restructuring”.
What was agreed (and as discussed in detail by us in Friday’s Global Economic Weekly) was that a final decision on Greece would only be made by the time the review report of the IMF mission is made available in June, with euro area heads of state making a final decision at the 24 June EU summit.
However, the second group of finance ministers reportedly still believes that there might be chance for Greece to sustain its debt service payments if new revenue-enhancing measures, expenditure cuts and privatization revenues were to be agreed and implemented. According to this group, Greece might still be able to return to international capital markets for funding in the course of the next year.
Crucially, a third proposal, namely to proceed with a financial top-up of the existing programme as soon as possible, seems not to have found any traction.
As discussed in our 11 May comprehensive update on Greece, “Greece: The (long) countdown to restructuring”, we do not believe that Greece is presently capable of avoiding unsustainable debt dynamics under most plausible economic and political scenarios, which is why we believe the discussion reportedly held at the Eurogroup meeting as to how to re-profile the Greek sovereign debt stock in a market-friendly fashion has merit
reserves, overall the report’s evaluation of the Bentley field was disappointing.
Estimated recoverable resources of 115mmbbl (2P+2C) from Bentley’s core area are
below both the previous CPR (122.5mmbbl) and management’s 120-250mmbbl
estimate for the Bentley field. While we believe Xcite’s share price will be
underpinned by its 2P reserve base, overall Xcite remains a risky proposition
relative to other E+Ps. We have reduced our target price from 453p to 225p, and our
recommendation moves from Buy to Add.
of 2P reserves for Bentley’s first stage production (FSP) phase, which we expect to
commence 4Q11. We see this as a positive result that partially derisks the asset, and
should underpin Xcite’s share price as the company moves into initial production. The
average EV/2P reserve multiple from a selection of global heavy oil peers is $13/boe,
underpinning Xcite at around 160p/share.
best case contingent resources for Bentley’s core area of 87mmbbl, suggesting
recoverable resource from this part of the field of 115mmbbl (i.e. 2P+2C). This is below
the previous CPR’s estimate of 122.5mmbbl and at the bottom end of management’s
120-250mmbbl estimate for the Bentley field.
for now we assume a smaller 115mmbbl Bentley development, i.e. the RAR’s
estimated 2P+2C resources. This is a conservative view we have taken in the absence
of any detail on Bentley’s resource potential beyond the core area. Secondly, we have
derisked our FSP valuation now that Xcite has been credited with 2P reserves – we
now assume a 90% CoS for this stage of the Bentley project. The overall impact on our
Xcite NAV is a 118p decrease to 335p/share.
E+P stocks. With the RAR now passed, there is a substantial length of time until the
next catalyst (first oil from the FSP, 4Q11) and continued uncertainty on the field’s
ultimately recoverable resource, in our view.
by a healthy 28mmbbl reserve base, and the stock remains inexpensive at just 0.57
times NAV versus the E+P peer group at 0.78 times. Our target price has moved from
453p to 225p, and with 17% upside to this target we move our recommendation from
Buy to Add.
