Markets Live chat transcript for the chat ending at 11:13 on 8 Jul 2010. Participants in this chat were: Neil Hume, FT Bryce Elder
NH
and welcome to Markets Live
NH
FT Alphaville’s daily markets chat
NH
he must be a very happy Senor this morning
BE
And Pulpo Paul was proved right again.
NH
that’s the sort of forecasting ability we could with in Muppet Fund Alpha
NH
one of our portfolio companies
NH
in a spot of bother today
Connaught Plc (CNT:LSE): Last: 112.80, down 5.2 (-4.41%), High: 122.80, Low: 109.90, Volume: 1.48m
NH
but we can come back to that later
BE
But I guess we should start at the top today.
NH
up another 57 ppoints to 5,077
NH
back through that important level
NH
and apparently it is all being pinned on the back of better than expected results
NH
and outlook statement from State Street overnight
NH
we could just be honest
NH
and say we don’t really know why it is up
NH
my guess is that all the risk taken off at the end of the second quarter
BE
Um …. solid Australian employment data?
BE
It’s simply risk on. Don’t fight the trend.
NH
but there is one thing
NH
that isn’t behind the rally
NH
and that’s the stress test
BE
Well, I guess there was nothing scary in the detail.
BE
Because there was no detail.
NH
but we don’t tell you why
BE
It’s not bad news. It is, at worst, inconsequential news.
BE
So how are the banks doing?
NH
pretty well as it happens
NH
leading today’s advance
Lloyds Banking Group plc (LLOY:LSE): Last: 59.93, up 1.74 (+2.99%), High: 61.98, Low: 59.70, Volume: 131.37m
Barclays PLC (BARC:LSE): Last: 298.70, up 7.1 (+2.43%), High: 306.05, Low: 286.80, Volume: 35.50m
NH
almost back through 300p
Royal Bank of Scotland Group PLC (RBS:LSE): Last: 43.88, up 1.05 (+2.45%), High: 45.61, Low: 43.41, Volume: 56.44m
NH
Merrill are pushing the stock today
NH
saying it could double in a couple of years
BE
Yeah – they’ve said that a few times.
BE
One of Helsby’s favourites.
BE
What’s the latest argument then?
NH
£1.8bn of Combined Business PBT in 1H10
NH
Analysts have been lifting EPS for Lloyds since the start of 2010, upgrading 2011
by over 60% – we think there is more to come. We forecast “Combined Business
PBT” in 2010 of £4.4bn (was £3.8bn) with £1.8bn in 1H10. Consensus looks for
£2.3bn in FY10. We think the interims will provide a catalyst for upgrades and a
re-rating in the share price more fitting of a c.17% 2012e RoNAV. Our PO is 100p,
based on a 2012 SoTP of 127p. 2 year view; we think the shares could double.
NH
Funding to focus on 2011
With c.£20bn of funding under its belt, we think Lloyds will be able to pre-fund its
2011 requirement of £20-25bn during 2H10. Stress tests and realisation of
stronger profits should lower Lloyds wholesale funding costs, in our view.
NH
Margins still going up…and up…and up
Investors have become increasingly sceptical that Lloyds will be able to boost
margins beyond the 2% promised for 2010. We are more bullish and think a
combination of continued back book repricing and lower short term funding costs
can see the Lloyds NIM back to 2.3-2.4% by 2012. If the Basel III NSFR ratio is
diluted or even scrapped margins could even get above 2.5%, we believe.
NH
Bad debts continue to improve
We forecast a 40% reduction in the level of 1H10 bad debts compared to 2H09.
Despite the UK austerity budget, we think bad debts will continue to normalise
toward c.70bp by 2012, as interest rates stay lower for longer. If we are wrong our
“HBOS2” stress test, suggests Lloyds core capital would not drop below c.7.5%.
NH
because the government allowed HBOS and Lloyds a monopoly position in lots of products
BE
Has he factored in increased competition from Metrobank?
NH
08Jul10 RTRS-LORD LEVENE, DAVID WALKER BACKING VEHICLE TO BID FOR UK RETAIL BANKS – SKY NEWS
09:25 08Jul10 RTRS-UK RETAIL BANK BID VEHICLE BACKED BY AVIVA, F&C, INVESCO – SKY NEWS
NH
here’s the full story from Kleinman wire
NH
The chairman of Lloyd’s of London and the man who last year led a review of corporate governance in the banking sector are drawing up secret plans to buy one of the banks owned by British taxpayers, I have learned.
Lord Levene of Portsoken and Sir David Walker are backing a new acquisition vehicle that will list on the London stock market and attempt to acquire a chunk of the high street banking industry. That’s likely to mean a bid for either Northern Rock or parts of Lloyds Banking Group which will have to be sold in return for the state aid it received following its emergency rescue of HBOS in 2008.
Details of the plans are likely to be announced within days. UK Financial Investments, the body which manages the taxpayer’s interests in the banking sector, is understood to have been briefed on the project as have the Treasury and executives at the banks themselves. Cenkos, the investment bank, and Kinmont, an advisory firm, are working on the proposals.
NH
have a history of never really taking off
NH
remember Sandy Chen at Panmure
NH
he was a banking analysts who tried to set up a new bank
BE
So – when was the last time a UK startup bank actually reached the point of taking deposits, Rabble?
NH
and they do face painting too
NH
a bit of comment on the stress test I think
NH
before we have a look at the HSBC/Nedbank story
NH
Here’s Bruce Packard from Seymour Pierce
NH
European Banks Stress Tests implications for UK banks
European regulators have released more details of their banking stress test exercise to simulate the impact of a severe economic shock on about 91 banks in the euro zone and other countries. The Committee of European Banking Supervisors (CEBS) said that the stress test would include 27 banks in Spain, 14 in Germany and 6 in Greece, but did not reveal the exact nature of the stress tests (e.g. what haircuts on sovereign debt would be assumed). German banking sources quoted by Reuters said the scenario assumed write-downs of 16-17 percent for some bonds from Greece and growth assumptions that are 1 to 2 percentage points below forecasts for eurozone countries. Portuguese debt would attract an 8% haircut, Spain 5%, with negligible write-down on German Government debt, according to FT
NH
Comment: By way of comparison, in April this year Argentina (which defaulted on $95bn in 2001) offered a 66% haircut on bonds due in 2033. In other recent crises the haircuts were not as severe (Russia 44%, Ecuador 25%, and Dominican Republic, Uruguay, Pakistan, Ukraine less than 15%). Credible stress tests in the UK and US generated confidence in the banking system last year. However, there is a fine line between tests that are suitably demanding, and reverse engineering a testing process so that everyone passes the test. Sources quoted by the FT suggest that 10 or 20 banks could fail. If the test is judged sufficiently credible, we could see a rally in more volatile UK banks names (BARC, HOLD TP 276p, RBS, SELL TP 36p).
BE
And here’s MF Global’s Simon Maughan
BE
Circularity. The US bank stress tests took place against a backdrop of fiscal and monetary stimulus and led to capital raising that restored confidence. The European tests do not have this favourable backdrop and most of the capital likely to be raised as a consequence of the tests will come from governments. This risks exacerbating sovereign debt concerns that necessitated stress tests in the first place. Thus we do not anticipate a surge in stock prices just because of the stress tests.
BE
A good result. However, estimates from the IMF already show that it is the unlisted sector that is most likely to fail the tests and so the most positive outcome from this exercise would be reform and recapitalisation of these banks. This would benefit listed banks through reduced competition, improved pricing and better access to savings. This outcome is already playing out in Spain to the benefit of BBVA and Santander.
BE
Winners and losers. Among the larger, listed banks it should surprise no one that we expect HSBC, Santander, BNP Paribas and UniCredit to fare better from the tests, while Credit Agricole, Deutsche Bank, Commerzbank and the Bank of Ireland will do worse. The use of government supplied capital to prop up core Tier 1 at a number of European institutions is likely to be a bone of contention for years.
BE
Greater nuance. A genuine surprise may be our conclusion that the likes of Santander and UniCredit would likely survive a sovereign default in their domestic markets without eroding their entire surplus core Tier 1. However, the aftermath of such an event would likely feature such a deep downturn that this would lead the strongest banks to seek more equity.
BE
A question of confidence. The media has already decided the outcome of the tests and bemoaned the absence of a plan to recapitalise the sector. However, it is not obvious to us that governments need to pre-fund recapitalisation, given the ultimate source of capital is taxpayers. The niggling issue is more likely to be the dispensation from strict application of Basel capital rules given to the likes of Credit Agricole and Commerzbank in order that they pass the tests.
BE
Time to Buy. Overall we are not convinced of the necessity of the stress tests, given the likely winners and losers appear obvious. However, as stock valuations are attractive and the market undiscerning between institutions, we will cheer the tests to the rafters if they flush out buyers for stocks such as Barclays, BNP Paribas and Santander, where earnings are recovering and underlying business growing.
NH
thanks for that. and here’s is a much more negative view from a sector watcher
NH
Stressing the Europe bank stress tests. We suggested two days ago that the EMU market focus will be primarily on this, and grow toward the 23 July publication date. This is partly because everyone is looking toward the US bank stress tests and the line that formed under the sand for risk appetite (ie, it bottomed). Banks failed the tests, capital had to be raised, and trust in financials rose as a result, a tail risk of financial doom was perceived to be removed.
NH
So equities loved the alleged (none of this is confirmed) news yesterday that there will be 17% haircut on Greece sovereigns, and 3% for Spain, and stressing for 3% lower GDP for EMU for 2010 & 2011 compared to EU forecasts.
NH
This is not stressful. They might as well not bother (you might disagree given the equity jump yesterday), and we suspect a cooler look at such stress would leave potential bank equity buyers disappointed. We have not met many clients in the past few months who really think that Greece will not default, it is no longer an extreme tail risk view, especially when many high quality estimates have Greece debt/GDP peaking at 149%.
NH
Stress tests should be stressful. Stress tests should not be about testing lightly for things which we could argue banks should be provisioning for already (ie, Greece 17% haircut).
NH
Now don’t anyone tell reader PDR
NH
about that Greek default line
BE
(Rabble: Tesco disqualified. Not an independent startup. Created via a joint venture with Natwest.)
BE
Well, we should look at this Nedbank retread I guess.
NH
this time HSBC interested
NH
previously it was Stan Chartered
NH
again another Kleinman story
NH
Old Mutual’s stake in Nedbank
NH
is going to go at some point
BE
That’s been an argument forever. Regulatory hurdles are considerable, but it should happen somehow, sometime.
NH
they have no operations to speak of in South Africa
NH
they said they wanted to benefit from the same trends as Stan Chart
NH
so I think we can safely say that are looking
NH
here’s the sector watcher again
NH
HSBC (Buy, GBP 8.25)
Sky reports that HSBC is assessing a takeover bid for Ned Bank in South Africa. This follows on reports from two months ago that Standard Chartered was in the early stages of buying Nedbank. We believe there is some credibility attached to this speculation given investment and trade flows between Africa and Asia and our view two months ago that if Standard Chartered was interested in Nedbank then HSBC was likely to take a look too. HSBC has historically had virtually no presence in Africa, but earlier this year stated an explicit ambition to benefit from the same economic trends as Standard Chartered is enjoying. We believe that Nedbank may well be too large and risky a deal for Standard Chartered to take on from a financial, strategic and shareholder value perspective. While the task is less daunting for HSBC we are if the opinion that depth not breadth is what the company should be pursuing at this time
Old Mutual PLC (OML:LSE): Last: 111.50, up 2.2 (+2.01%), High: 112.90, Low: 110.50, Volume: 4.89m
HSBC Holdings PLC (HSBA:LSE): Last: 617.00, up 2.3 (+0.37%), High: 619.70, Low: 612.50, Volume: 12.75m
Standard Chartered PLC (STAN:LSE): Last: 1,709, up 15 (+0.89%), High: 1,728, Low: 1,695, Volume: 1.78m
BE
Right – Bundesbank’s keen to talk about the MPC for some reason.
BE
No change, either on rate or APF, I guess.
NH
will hardly be worth looking at
NH
the ECB press conference on the other hand
NH
you won’t believe this
NH
but the fire alarm has gone off
NH
we are being asked to leave the building
NH
we could be missing for some time
NH
we will leave the session open
BE
The building does not actually appear to be on fire.
NH
we will be back in five mins
NH
why does this always happen to us
NH
here’s some dinner party live
NH
house prices are falling in the UK
NH
The Halifax reported that house prices fell by 0.6% month-on-month in June. This followed drops of 0.5% in May and 0.1% in April, and was the fourth decline in the past five months (the exception being a rise of 1.0% in March). Consequently, the year-on-year increase in house prices moderated to 6.3% in the three months to June from 6.9% in the three months to May. The year-on-year increase narrowed to 4.8% in June itself from 5.2% in May and a peak of 8.7% in April.
The Halifax data follow on from the Nationwide reporting that the rise in house prices slowed to just 0.1% in June from 0.5% in May and 1.1% in April. The year-on-year rise in house prices moderated appreciably to 8.7% in June from 9.8% in May and 10.5% in April on the Nationwide measure.
The third successive drop in prices reported by the Halifax in June adds to a recent flurry of soft data on the housing market and stokes our relative pessimism over the housing market. Indeed, we increasingly suspect that house prices will be only flat over the rest of this year. We had previously thought a small rise was possible.
NH
Housing market activity is currently relatively low, the economic fundamentals are far from ideal for the housing market (high unemployment, still falling full-time employment and muted wage growth), a major fiscal squeeze is now starting, and house price/earnings ratios have moved back up overall from their early-2009 lows and are above their long-term averages. Specifically, Halifax data show that the ratio of house prices to earnings stood at 4.72% in June compared to a low of 4.34% in April 2009. This is above the 1983-2010 average of 4.01%.
There are also concerns that the Bank of England will raise interest rates before the end of the year due to sticky, above-target inflation. Furthermore, if household confidence suffers from widespread significant doubts about the stability and longevity of the Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition governments, this could impact negatively on the housing market.
Meanwhile, more properties are coming on to the market thereby moving the supply/demand balance more in favour of buyers. This is particularly relevant as a shortage of properties has been a key factor in the recovery in house prices from their early-2009 lows. It may well be that the new government’s decision to abolish Home Information Packs is now contributing to the rise in houses coming on to the market.
On the positive side, some support for house activity and prices will come from the current stamp duty holiday for first-time buyers on all properties costing up to £250,000. And interest rates are likely to stay low for an extended period to offset the fiscal tightening.
On balance, we believe that house prices are likely to be erratic over the coming months and will probably be only flat over the rest of 2010. Furthermore, it is hard at this stage to be optimistic about house prices in 2011 as the fiscal squeeze will increasingly kick in, which will hit people’s pockets and lead to serious job losses in the public sector.
BE
Okay – we’re getting evicted.
BE
DISCLAIMER: WE WILL BAN WITHOUT MERCY ANYONE WHO MUCKS ABOUT IN THE DEAD AIR THAT FOLLOWS.
NH
and not even a show from Blue Watch
NH
we are the only people in the newsroom at the moment
NH
a few people filing in now
NH
anything need zapping?
BE
I’m trying to read through the comments as quickly as possible.
BE
It seems most people behaved themselves.
BE
Well done, Rabble. Give yourselves a gold star.
NH
I almost don’t believe it
NH
consider the bigot tag removed
BE
Um – MPC, before we were so rudely interupted.
BE
The gist being, unchanged, with the main uncertainty regarding whether Sentance stays a hawk.
NH
there will be questions about the stress test
NH
and the risk in money market rates
NH
let’s get back to stocks
NH
and a Muppet Fund portfolio company
Connaught Plc (CNT:LSE): Last: 110.70, down 7.3 (-6.19%), High: 122.80, Low: 109.90, Volume: 1.66m
NH
one day I will type that in wrong
NH
this stock is starting to smell really bad
NH
that we might have to double the position
NH
who is fighting a rear guard action
NH
to protect his reputation
NH
has launched a review into accounting polocoes
NH
the outcome of that can’t be good, right?
BE
Restatement, one would imagine.
BE
That’s what Investec thinks anyway.
BE
there are signs of a new
beginning at Connaught. However, we continue to believe there are significant
hurdles to overcome, including a potential restatement of profits and further
poor news flow on trading. Sell with a new target of 89p.
NH
stock holding up well, however
NH
I just can’t help feeling more skeltons will emerge
NH
whether it is regional branch of PWC
NH
that’s usually the way these things go
BE
rror 404 – Page Not Found
The page you are looking for can not be found, it has either expired or doesn’t exist on the server.
Please use the links or search to locate the page.
BE
In other words, “Move on, nothing to see here”.
NH
right a bit more comment
NH
Connaught’s CEO, Mark Tincknell, and FD, Stephen Hill, are to leave their positions.
New Chairman, Roy Gardner, has decided to act on the concerns that came to a head
with the profits warning less than two weeks ago.
Mr Gardner has also launched an independent review of the accounting policy for
mobilisation costs (currently large mobilisation costs are capitalised).
This all leaves the group in limbo. We’d be inclined to stay on the sidelines until we have
better clarity of precisely what is under there. SELL.
BE
Though for balance, some people are encouraged.
BE
Reconfirming revised full year guidance and no change to forecasts – The
statement notes that despite recent events which have already been reflected in
expectations, the business continues to perform well and that the outlook remains
robust. No further news on Social Housing’s performance (earlier comments on
revenue and profit reductions have been reconfirmed). Environmental and
Compliance both look to be trading reasonably resiliently. We are not planning to
change our estimates.
BE
Uncertainties remain – Sentiment is likely to remain negative for the foreseeable
future. There are a number of concerns which need to be addressed, including
whether the recent problems reflect more challenging underlying problems and
what impact the significant share price fall may have had on the businesses
performance (be it employee engagement, client concerns etc.). Management
changes (although may be received well by some) also add uncertainty with
regards to the longer term direction. Until cash generation improves which looks
like it could take some time, confidence is likely to remain fragile.
BE
Price target and recommendation – If investors can get comfortable with market
forecasts, then undoubtedly there is significant value in the shares from this level.
However, we believe that this could take a long time. Given the uncertainty and
concerns, in our view, it is too early to buy into a recovery in a meaningful way.
We have reduced our Price Target to 135p (220p), 6.5x FY10 EBITA, although
move to ADD from HOLD as we could see the shares ticking up slightly from a low
base.
NH
and a non-executive has stepped up to the plate this morning and bought 20,000 shares at 112.5p each.
NH
good luck with that one Robert
NH
if we back up the truck we do it in style
BE
Ah – he’s the former Capita guy.
BE
Robert, 68, was a Non-Executive Director at Capita Group plc for 12 years and Chairman of Capita’s Audit Committee from 1993 to 2007. He is a Senior Non-Executive Director and Chairman of the Audit Committee at Huntsworth plc and Senior Independent Director of Leed Petroleum plc.
BE
Yes we shall. It’s nearly MPC time already.
BE
I’ve lost track of where we are.
NH
(Lemmy the new US shareholder is activist)
NH
I had loads of stuff lined up
NH
I do have a bit of comment from the sector watcher on Bowleven
BowLeven PLC (BLVN:LSE): Last: 144.75, up 0.75 (+0.52%), High: 148.00, Low: 144.50, Volume: 613.09k
NH
The group is currently drilling the first of three potentially game-changing wells offshore Cameroon in West Africa. The IE-3 appraisal well spudded on 7th May and was scheduled to take 60 days (although it could take longer if testing is required). The objective of the well is to confirm the commerciality of the IE gas/condensate discovery, testing the main Isongo sands as well as the shallower Biafra gas target. Proving commerciality should lead to a rapid development of the field through gas recycling to produce the condensate. BLVN and its 25% partner Vitol will then drill the high impact exploration prospect MLHP-5, which will be followed by an appraisal well on the IF discovery.
NH
Assuming success at the two IE/IF appraisal wells, BLVN will be hoping to shift a material proportion of its 217m barrels oil equivalent contingent resources into reserves. On an unrisked basis we believe these could be worth in the order of $1.8bn gross, or $720m net to BLVN (which assumes Vitol exercises its option for a further 25% stake and a 20% state back-in), or 250p/share. Add on a further 50p/share for the assumed cash balance post-Vitol and we see the scope for a price >300p/share. Moreover this attributes zero value for exploration upside from the likes of MLHP-5. Kevin Hart has had a torrid time at BLVN since assuming the CEO role four years ago (shares have traded a range of 25-425p), but things could be about to take a turn for the better. We remain big BUYERS of the stock.
NH
(keep it clean with Alcock gags pls)
NH
asking about Northumbrian Water
NH
and the latest bid story
Northumbrian Water Group PLC (NWG:LSE): Last: 319.50, up 1.2 (+0.38%), High: 326.10, Low: 319.10, Volume: 644.86k
BE
I think the share price reaction tells its own story.
BE
We’ve heard endless speculation about Ontario’s intentions.
NH
which seem to be linked with everything
NH
we need to make a correction
NH
because I can’t bear to have another email from this woman
NH
Bryce, Neil,
Further to today’s coverage in The FT I would like to bring to your attention an incorrect statement within the market report.
In your article you make a reference QIA in terms of a potential bid for Sainsbury. I would like to bring it to your attention that QIA does not make direct equity investments, any direct equity investments are made by Qatar Holding, the direct investment arm of the Qatar Investment Authority.
We wanted to ensure that you were aware of this so the same mistake is not made in the future.
Many thanks and regards,
BE
I think you’ll find I wrote ….
BE
QIA’s investment arm, Sainsbury’s 26 per cent shareholder,
BE
Oh, since we’re in smallcap corner.
NH
we have the BOE statement
NH
The Bank of England’s Monetary Policy Committee today voted to maintain the official Bank Rate paid on commercial bank reserves at 0.5%. The Committee also voted to maintain the stock of asset purchases financed by the issuance of central bank reserves at £200 billion.
The minutes of the meeting will be published at 9.30am on Wednesday 21 July.
BE
Oh, nowt interesting really.
BE
Decent-ish trading update ahead of an analyst visit
NH
Slough to look at replica sports kits
BE
Here’s Nick Coulter at Numis, who’s looking forward to his visit to “Windsor’s fundament.”
BE
JJB will today be hosting an investor trip to the re-laid Slough store, which has
delivered encouraging gap growth of 10% in the six week period since re-opening.
With LFLs and gross margin trending in-line with expectations, and a sharp
movement in the stock price since the prelims, we move to BUY from Add.
BE
Initial re-lay of Slough store delivers 10% LFL gap growth: The Slough store
re-opened on 21 May after a re-lay focusing on layout and navigation. Building on the
recovery in the underlying portfolio, the store is showing gap sales growth of 10%
above a control group. This represents an extremely encouraging outturn given the
format iterations and inventory profile to come.
BE
6wk Group LFLs of +22% and gross margin in-line: LFLs for the six weeks to 4 July
were +22% with gross margin at 43.9%. This is ahead of the May run rate (+19%) with
progress in-line with our expectations. As a further point of note, JJB’s clearance sale
commenced 10 days later than last year, boding well for the continued recovery of the
group’s gross margin.
BE
Raising to BUY after recent share price weakness: Following a weak share price
performance since the prelims update, we move to BUY. JJB now trades on 7.5x our
Jan-12 EPS forecast, reflecting a 3.5% EBIT margin with scope for material sales and
margin progression in the medium term.
NH
just back to the BOE for a moment
NH
what looks like 500 words post statement
NH
While Andrew Sentance highly likely voted for an interest rate hike again, we have serious doubts that any of the other seven current MPC members joined him (Martin Weale joins the MPC in time for the August meeting). Admittedly, all MPC members are likely to be concerned by still sticky, well above-target consumer price inflation and a recent spike up in short-term inflation expectations, but there are currently very serious risks to the already muted recovery coming from the extra fiscal tightening measures that were announced in June’s emergency budget, as well as from the Eurozone’s problems and heightened fears of a global “double-dip”.
NH
We think it is more likely than not that the Bank of England will keep interest rates down at 0.50% through the rest of 2010 and perhaps well into 2011. This reflects our suspicion that recovery will be bumpy and gradual overall during the coming months amid ongoing difficult conditions. However, we acknowledge that there is a very real chance of at least a token interest rate hike before the end of the year if inflation continues to be sticky and inflation expectations rise significantly further.
We had expected interest rates to start rising in February 2011, but this looks questionable with the economy already set to be hit by Value Added Tax rising from 17.5% to 20% next January. So the first rate hike may well be delayed until the second quarter. And when interest rates do start to rise, the increases are likely to be very gradual and limited due to the need to keep monetary policy loose to counter the major fiscal squeeze. Specifically, we see interest rates only rising to 1.75% by the end of 2011.
NH
do you have anything else
BE
I guess we can have a quick whiparound the sellside-influenced movers.
Aggreko PLC (AGK:LSE): Last: 1,511, up 49 (+3.35%), High: 1,537, Low: 1,485, Volume: 640.46k
BE
However, HSBC looks to have enjoyed the last junkett.
BE
Matthew Lloyd’s very positive in a start of the business services sector.
BE
We initiate Experian, Mears, Aggreko, Northgate, Regus at Overweight, retain
Overweight recommendations on Bunzl, Electrocomponents and Premier Farnell. We initiate
USG and Ashtead at Underweight, and retain Underweight on Wolseley, Adecco,
Randstad, Hays, and Michael Page. We initiate at Neutral on Capita, Xchanging,
G4S, Securitas, Davis Service Group and Mitie. We retain Neutral ratings
on Rentokil, Serco, SThree and WS Atkins.
NH
so why isn’t its rival?
BE
It’s only 257 pages long, this thing. Perhaps they didn’t have space to mention it.
BE
Matthew Lloyd, Alex Magni, Rajesh Kumar
BE
And finally, National Grid
BE
Three Issues Key to NG’s Future — Now the dust has settled on the surprise
£3.2bn rights issue, three issues will in our view now determine NG’s future – the
UK capex surge, how the capex / dividend is funded, and the likely strategic
review of NG’s US operations.
Government Policy Drives Capex Surge — The new UK government so far seems
committed to the environmental targets it inherited. These targets require the UK
electricity and gas industry to invest c.£200bn out to 2020. In response, NG has
upped its capex from £2bn pa in 2006 to a new run rate of £4.4bn pa. Unless
government policy changes, NG’s capex is only likely to rise further.
BE
The Funding Problem — NG could not meet this surge in capex and pay its
dividend by adding debt without a ratings downgrade. NG could have cancelled its
dividend to fund the growth, but instead raised £3.2bn in new equity to pay back
£1.2bn pa in dividends. Which begs the question – what is the true value of NG’s
apparently high 7.3% yield?
NG’s US Business — NG can expect much greater scrutiny of its US business from
shareholders, where performance has been increasingly disappointing. In our
view, NG’s rationale for continued ownership has been significantly undermined
by events and therefore a strategic review is likely. If the business were to be sold
for an EV north of £12bn then we calculate NG could avoid another equity
issuance.
BE
Valuation and Investment Recommendation — Our revised S-O-P based valuation
reduces our target price from 565p (pro-forma) to 500p. Consequently, we move
our rating to Hold/Medium Risk (2M) from Buy/Medium Risk (1M). We also update
our forecasts for latest guidance and the company’s new capex plans.
NH
Looks to me as if the ROTR are bored. Lack of comments suggests that we should we this up. I have completely lost my thread because of the fire alarm. Let’s come back refreshed tomorrow
NH
thanks for logging in rabble
NH
hope to see you all again tomorrow
NH
and look out for an alphaville letter
NH
to Ocada chairman Michael Grade later today
NH
we have some questions
NH
Grade is a real details man