Markets Live chat transcript for the chat ending at 12:12 on 9 Mar 2010. Participants in this chat were: Neil Hume, FT Bryce Elder
NH
Hola
NH
and welcome to Markets Live
NH
FT Alphaville’s daily markets round up
NH
and happy first birthday
NH
to the bull market
NH
one years old today
BE
Morning everyone.
NH
yep, it was a year ago today that the S&P hit 666 intraday
NH
and it felt like the world was about to end
NH
so how is the bull market today?
BE
having a bit of sulk
BE
FTSE down 36 points
BE
Gradual slide from its 18-month high
BE
looks to be feeling a bit tired.
BE
Needs a rest.
NH
hmmm
NH
sterling being kicked again, though
NH
back below the psychologically important $1.50 level
NH
after some pretty awful trade data, which seems to put into doubt
NH
the idea that weak sterling will help rebalance the UK economy
BE
Oh noes. Not the psychologically important $1.50 level ….
NH
GBK close to its lows for the day
NH
$1.4945
NH
that’s cable obviously
NH
and a euro thingy buys 0.9079p
NH
actually this trade data
NH
was pretty shocking
NH
exports fell sharply in January
NH
while imports
NH
came off just a touch
BE
Give us Archer’s take then.
BE
Please.
NH
hang on
NH
just scanning the note
NH
for a mention of the weather
NH
don’t think I can see anything
NH
There is no getting away from the fact that the January trade data are disappointing and also worrying for hopes that the economy can rebalance over the coming months. The total trade deficit widened to a 17-month high in January as exports worryingly fell appreciably and imports declined modestly. This suggests that net trade is set to be a drag on the economy in the first quarter of 2010 as it was in both the fourth and third quarters of 2009. Specifically, net trade lopped 0.2 percentage point off GDP growth of 0.3% quarter-on-quarter in the fourth quarter of 2009 and contributed 0.3 percentage point to the third quarter contraction of 0.3% quarter-on-quarter.
NH
The biggest disappointment in the January trade data was a 6.2% month-on-month drop in traded goods excluding oil.
BE
(M43cap – because the price used to be transmitted by the first ever transatlantic cable.)
NH
Even allowing for the fact that both exports and imports could well have been limited in January by the very bad weather hitting the UK and other countries, the fact that exports fell appreciably more than imports is worrying news and it heightens concerns as to whether or not net trade can make a decent positive contribution to growth going forward and help the economy to rebalance.
NH
hang on
NH
Weather is mentioned
NH
excellent
NH
We are still hopeful that net trade will make a positive contribution to UK growth in 2010 as car imports wind down as the car scrappage scheme comes to an end and overall imports are limited by likely gradually improving domestic demand. Meanwhile, exports will hopefully be lifted by a competitive pound and improved global growth and trade. Unfortunately though, this is very far from guaranteed, and current signs that Eurozone growth is struggling for momentum is a serious worry for UK exporters.
BE
So all pretty dismal stuff then.
NH
yep
NH
not good
NH
but hey
NH
if the weather improves
NH
then I am sure exports will
BE
Hm.
NH
right
NH
let’s cut to ther wider market
11:10AM
NH
and let’s just reflect for a moment on Pearson
Pearson plc is the parent company of the Financial Times, publisher of FT Alphaville.
Pearson (PSON:LSE): Last: 1,000, up 1.5 (+0.15%), High: 1,006, Low: 996.50, Volume: 909.05k
BE
(Tartan: yes, but a small one. See yesterday’s transcript.)
NH
look at that £10
BE
NH
and guess what
NH
I have no cheap SAYE shares
NH
and nor does Bryce
BE
Nope.
NH
BE
Didn’t pick up any of that free money
BE
Dolts.
NH
yes, not good
NH
anyway
NH
what else is mocing today?
BE
Well, there’s a few results stories around obviously.
NH
(Tuna – a smaller mortgage and more free cash flow would help also)
NH
not sure
NH
some results out
NH
International Power
NH
Inmarsat
NH
Shanks has ended takeover talks with private equity
NH
and then there is UK Coal
NH
and its odd takeover statement
NH
or what about
NH
the banks note from Jonathan Pierce
NH
very pessmistic
BE
Ok – let’s start at the end.
BE
Doom and gloom for the banks please.
NH
(Tuna – i wish Tuna, I wish. Give up my Sky subscription)
NH
ok
11:13AM
NH
So Pierce
NH
is the highly rated banks guy at Credit Suisse
NH
and he really doesn’t like the UK banks
NH
thinks they are up with events
NH
and he seems frustrated that no one can see the large elephants in the room
NH
such as new liquidity rules
NH
funding constraints
BE
And this seems to have encouraged some folk to take some cash off the table.
Royal Bank of Scotland Group PLC (RBS:LSE): Last: 38.09, down 1.38 (-3.50%), High: 39.80, Low: 38.05, Volume: 34.43m
Lloyds Banking Group PLC (LLOY:LSE): Last: 52.85, down 0.8 (-1.49%), High: 54.04, Low: 52.80, Volume: 85.23m
Barclays PLC (BARC:LSE): Last: 338.70, down 6.3 (-1.83%), High: 347.00, Low: 335.50, Volume: 27.14m
NH
hmmm
NH
right
NH
want to see some of the note
BE
Sure
NH
Elephants in the room
NH
Investment thesis rests on revenue: Normalising profits for impairment
leaves ROTE close to COE. But shares imply ROTE above COE by 2013.
To buy the banks, one must assume revenues rise from here, in our view;
leaves ROTE close to COE. But shares imply ROTE above COE by 2013.
To buy the banks, one must assume revenues rise from here, in our view;
NH
The balance sheet is key: While the precise timing of new liquidity
requirements is unclear, we believe banks must improve balance sheet
structures over the next 3-4 years. This will be difficult through term issuance
alone, and we believe that balance sheet footings will have to shrink
markedly (£200-530bn or over 10%) to compensate;
requirements is unclear, we believe banks must improve balance sheet
structures over the next 3-4 years. This will be difficult through term issuance
alone, and we believe that balance sheet footings will have to shrink
markedly (£200-530bn or over 10%) to compensate;
NH
Revenue headwind of £4-10bn: Applying a 2% margin to this asset
reduction implies a loss of 10-25% of net interest income. Granted, margins
should improve, but absolute revenue will stagnate, in our view.
reduction implies a loss of 10-25% of net interest income. Granted, margins
should improve, but absolute revenue will stagnate, in our view.
NH
De-leveraging also driven by capital: It’s not about DTA’s, minorities or
other easily dismissible items – the issue is RWA which we think could inflate
35% on new BIS rules. In particular, we are still concerned by CCR RWA
which we think could increase several-fold, pre-mitigation
other easily dismissible items – the issue is RWA which we think could inflate
35% on new BIS rules. In particular, we are still concerned by CCR RWA
which we think could increase several-fold, pre-mitigation
NH
Things could be worse: If market conditions deteriorate, fixing the balance
sheet will be even more costly. Shrinking assets will get harder anyway – QE
substantially helped banks (particularly liquid assets) and that has ended.
sheet will be even more costly. Shrinking assets will get harder anyway – QE
substantially helped banks (particularly liquid assets) and that has ended.
NH
We think the sector is at best fair value for now. In relative terms,
Barclays (Outperform) is our favourite bank with a 375p target price (from
350p). LBG is Neutral with a 50p target (unchanged). RBS is Underperform
with a 35p target (unchanged).
Barclays (Outperform) is our favourite bank with a 375p target price (from
350p). LBG is Neutral with a 50p target (unchanged). RBS is Underperform
with a 35p target (unchanged).
BE
So – RBS at 35p
NH
yep
NH
actually
NH
anymore on this Barclays fund raising rumour?
NH
the last I heard
NH
is the £6bn was done
NH
and some usually sensible people had heard the rumour
NH
they might not have believed it
NH
but they had heard it
BE
Hm. There’s nothing firmer out there at the moment it seems.
BE
The rumour’s out there, but there remains the tricky question of “why?”
NH
well
NH
looking at 2012
NH
and the impact of the Basel III rules
NH
Barc will be facing a capital shortfall
NH
as will the rest of the sector
NH
but there are ways it can be plugged
NH
flogging the stake in Blackrock
NH
would be one way
NH
(Tuna – spanish waiter)
BE
Yeah – but £6bn now is more likely to draw attention to the issue than fix it, I’d argue.
BE
Seems too early and too little.
NH
true
NH
probably nonsense
NH
but anyway
11:20AM
NH
There is a better bit of RAW going round this morning
RAW is market chatter – information that has not been formally tested through traditional journalistic channels (PRs etc). The story might be complete rubbish, but if we believe there is some substance to it we will say so. Either way, Reader Beware.
BE
Excellent – what’s that?
NH
Temenos
BE
Aha!
NH
banking software
NH
competes with Misys
Strange software outfit, seemingly controlled by US investor ValueAct Capital.
BE
Yeah – sort -of. Temenos is the number one, while Misys is an also ran.
NH
a bit smaller though
NH
Temenos is
BE
Temenos market share is 14% or thereabouts. Clear #1. Misys is about #6.
BE
Anyway, what’s the rumour?
NH
that it is being stalked
NH
SAP is the name in the frame
NH
now as you all know
NH
I am no expert on software companies
NH
Autonomy aside
NH
so I don’t know if that makes sense
NH
and SAP is probably the most boring companu in Europe
BE
Indeed. Up there with Bunzl.
NH
So the story is SAP interested
NH
could pay up EUR40
NH
but I note
NH
that SAP just parted company with its CEO
NH
has a dual-headed structure now
NH
and is sort of lukewarm towards acquisitions
BE
Co-CEOs Bill McDermott and Jim Hagemann-Snabe
BE
Although they have made a big play, most recently at this year’s CeBit, that there’s no disruption from the change at the top
NH
(Sorry shovel – CHF 40)
BE
Strategy remains in order
BE
And this would make some sense
NH
go on
BE
Temenos is priced at about 15 or 16 times 2010 earnings, which is not that expensive for a software company.
BE
Never mind one that’s got a laundry list of tier-one customers
BE
And SAP would be going up against its old foe Oracle, which is #2 or thereabouts
NH
hmmm funny you should mention that
NH
because Oracle being mentioned as a potential gatecrashed
NH
should SAP and Temenos ever get it together
BE
Plausible I guess.
BE
Although I’d also have an eye on Indian companies such as Infosys and Tata
BE
Which are the ones who have been making real inroads.
NH
yes, they always get run up the flag pole
NH
anyway
NH
these rumours aren’t helping Misys
NH
which has taken a bit of kick today
Misys PLC (MSY:LSE): Last: 235.20, down 8.4 (-3.45%), High: 241.90, Low: 234.50, Volume: 1.94m
NH
and that’s because Citi have slapped a sell rating on them
NH
Timing — We continue to disagree with MSY on timing. In our January note, we
argued that US Healthcare stimulus is unlikely to drive EHR adoption by 65% to
85% in just 5 years. At the BankFusion (BF) launch, MSY set another tough target
– 250 BF clients live, which would make it the fastest core banking rollout ever.
argued that US Healthcare stimulus is unlikely to drive EHR adoption by 65% to
85% in just 5 years. At the BankFusion (BF) launch, MSY set another tough target
– 250 BF clients live, which would make it the fastest core banking rollout ever.
NH
WIP — Front-end of BF looks encouraging but back-end (core data layer) is
unproven. This seems to be reflected in a market launch where Bankmaster
customers get whole new product, while Midas/ Equation customers receive a
“wrapper”.
unproven. This seems to be reflected in a market launch where Bankmaster
customers get whole new product, while Midas/ Equation customers receive a
“wrapper”.
NH
Proof-in-pudding — BF has signed 8 clients so far – mainly small banks/ branch
which seems to suggest that customers are testing the system before a major rollout.
which seems to suggest that customers are testing the system before a major rollout.
NH
Healthcare Update — Since our last note, the US government has worked on
initiatives to speed up the process of bringing certified software to market. While
this should bring the date for fully certified product forward by c2-3 months (fall
2010), it means we view a take-off in demand as unlikely until CY11.
initiatives to speed up the process of bringing certified software to market. While
this should bring the date for fully certified product forward by c2-3 months (fall
2010), it means we view a take-off in demand as unlikely until CY11.
NH
SELL — At 25x CY10E and 19.5x CY11E (on our below consensus EPS) the stock
looks to be pricing in these ambitious targets. We believe the stock will be
sensitive to short-term newsflow on both strategies and that any disappointment
could test this generous valuation – SELL.
looks to be pricing in these ambitious targets. We believe the stock will be
sensitive to short-term newsflow on both strategies and that any disappointment
could test this generous valuation – SELL.
BE
That comes after Misys held an investor meeting last week about the Bankfusion product.
NH
what?
BE
Which apparently looks pretty good.
BE
But Misys has basically starved development of its banking arm for years, so it has a mountain to climb to regain even the second- and third-rate banks that used to be its customers
BE
Right – think I’ve nerded out enough now.
NH
DLC – thanks for you comment. Interesting and I guess Temenos
NH
would not be a big acquisition for SAP
NH
right
NH
we need a Temenos price
BE
So we’re up 2.1% at 29.15 Swiss francs
NH
ta
NH
right,
NH
bored with banking software
BE
I could never be bored of banking software, but I’m just a bit weird like that. Anyway, let’s move on.
NH
let’s
11:30AM
BE
Ok – how about UK Coal?
NH
Oh yes
NH
bid rumours in the Mail today
NH
which prompted this statement
NH
from the company
NH
UK COAL has noted the speculation in today’s Daily Mail relating to a purported proposal for a cash offer for the Group. UK COAL is not aware of any such proposal from the Group’s major shareholder or any other source.
NH
NH
so far, so clear
NH
but then things get a little more complex
NH
The Group is at a very early stage of investigating an approach it has received which could address the Group’s exposure to the volatile performance of its deep mines through a merger transaction. It is emphasised that this proposal is highly conditional and at a very preliminary stage and no view can be expressed as to whether a transaction will result.
NH
As has been reported to the market, the Group has encountered continuing difficulties in the performance of its deep mines in recent months, which is having a material impact on its financial position. At Daw Mill, as previously reported, preparation for production at the new face was hindered by difficult geological conditions and, as a result, the start of production on the new face is now expected during April rather than around the end of March. The exposure of the Group to the volatile performance in its deep mines is a significant concern to the directors and mitigating the effects of this exposure, by operating improvements or structural means, is a priority.
NH
So
NH
it is in talks
NH
but to merger its deep coal assets
NH
possible buyers for that
NH
could be ATH
NH
or Hargreaves Services
NH
but the point here is
NH
UK Coal needs to get rid of these assets
NH
they are putting a huge strain on cashflow
NH
in fact such a strain
NH
that another cash call is not beynd the realms of possibility
NH
so no one should expect a fancy price of the assets
NH
although it would be good if they went
UK COAL PLC (UKC:LSE): Last: 57.50, up 5 (+9.52%), High: 60.00, Low: 54.75, Volume: 9.19m
BE
But is this half-story worth 9.5% on yesterday’s price?
NH
pass
NH
but these mines are a drain
NH
that’s for sure
BE
Hang on – didn’t we spend much of last week talking about the coal price going through the roof?
NH
we did
BE
And how the weaker pound would benefit exporters such as … er .. UK Coal
NH
just scratching around for some comment on UK Coal
NH
nothing fresh
NH
but I do have something from Evo Secs
NH
dated March 4
NH
Indeed, assuming that the work to access the Beeston and Deep Soft seams at
Kellingley and Thoresby is successful, and that UK Coal overcomes the problems
at Daw Mill, it should be in a position to build output significantly over the
remainder of 2010. This should offer significant benefits in 2011.
Kellingley and Thoresby is successful, and that UK Coal overcomes the problems
at Daw Mill, it should be in a position to build output significantly over the
remainder of 2010. This should offer significant benefits in 2011.
NH
We recognise that the group is currently cash-constrained and is working hard to
reduce unnecessary expenditure and working capital commitments. If, however,
UK Coal needs to raise cash then we believe that it could sell property assets,
albeit that selling now would not offer the ability to extract maximum value
reduce unnecessary expenditure and working capital commitments. If, however,
UK Coal needs to raise cash then we believe that it could sell property assets,
albeit that selling now would not offer the ability to extract maximum value
NH
While we recognise the market’s near-term cash flow concerns, we note that the
company is working hard to keep costs under control and reduce working capital
requirements. We believe that this will be enhanced by the recent appointment of a
new director of mining who has been charged with improving the operating
performance of the business.
company is working hard to keep costs under control and reduce working capital
requirements. We believe that this will be enhanced by the recent appointment of a
new director of mining who has been charged with improving the operating
performance of the business.
BE
(@John: yes, fair point. Coking versus thermal.)
NH
right
NH
I have some break down
NH
on deep mines vs suface mines at UK Coal
NH
so this year deep mines expected to produce 5.7m tonnes
NH
of the deep stuff
NH
vs 1.3m of the light stuff
NH
but expected to lose £100m
NH
OKay
NH
bored with Coal
BE
Fair enough.
11:39AM
NH
and as one deal begins
NH
another ends
NH
Shanks Group
Shanks Group PLC (SKS:LSE): Last: 103.80, down 16.6 (-13.79%), High: 106.50, Low: 95.90, Volume: 8.90m
BE
Hm. Not a healthy reaction.
BE
Although I guess they’re not back to 90p, which is where they were when the offer first went in.
NH
indeed it could have been worse
NH
in fact
NH
some people think Carlyle might return
NH
and go hostile
NH
and note
NH
Shanks remains in an offer period
NH
because Carlyle have not issued a statement
NH
we have only had comment from Shanks
NH
The Board of Shanks Group PLC (“Shanks” or the “Group”) announces that it has ended discussions with Carlyle Europe Partners III Participations S.à r.l. SICAR, a fund managed by The Carlyle Group (“Carlyle”), about a possible offer for Shanks.
The Board of Shanks Group PLC (“Shanks” or the “Group”) announces that it has ended discussions with Carlyle Europe Partners III Participations S.à r.l. SICAR, a fund managed by The Carlyle Group (“Carlyle”), about a possible offer for Shanks.
NH
As previously announced, the Group has been in discussions with a private equity firm, subsequently confirmed as Carlyle, since its approach in October 2009. During this period, Shanks engaged constructively with Carlyle and their advisers, who were granted extensive access both to information on the Group and its key personnel across Europe. At a meeting yesterday between the Chairman of Shanks and Carlyle, a final price indication of 120p cash per share was proposed by Carlyle for all the issued share capital of Shanks. The Board of Shanks has subsequently met and concluded that it is unwilling to recommend an offer at such a level and accordingly that further discussions with Carlyle are not in the interests of Shanks shareholders.
NH
The Group remains committed to a focused strategy around its three principal growth areas of recycling, organic processing and UK PFI. Whilst trading conditions for the waste industry across Europe remain challenging reflecting the weak macro-economic environment, the Board is very confident in the Group’s longer term prospects. A combination of compelling drivers for the waste industry, improved operational and balance sheet gearing and recent decisive action by the strengthened management team positions the Group for attractive medium term growth.
NH
So 120p offer
NH
not surprising they rejected that
NH
shareholders wanted 150p
NH
and I think Carlyle tried the old something came up in DD
NH
as the reason for the lower
NH
indeed DD took a long time in this deal
NH
which nearly always is a huge warning sign
NH
from what I have been hearing
NH
the deal really collapsed because of funding
NH
and pressure from Carlyle’s US HQ
BE
That’s an interesting theory.
BE
Carlyle was short of funding?
NH
well not sure
NH
but it looked very tight/ambitious
NH
anyway
NH
I have a bit of comment on this
NH
from the new merger research function at JP Morgan Cazenove
NH
Shanks has rejected an indicative offer of 120p/share from Carlyle
following extensive discussions. Discussions have now ended with the
Board arguing that Carlyle’s offer “failed to offer a price which
properly reflects the value of the Group [and] the Board is confident
that the Group can deliver attractive growth in shareholder value over
the medium term.”
following extensive discussions. Discussions have now ended with the
Board arguing that Carlyle’s offer “failed to offer a price which
properly reflects the value of the Group [and] the Board is confident
that the Group can deliver attractive growth in shareholder value over
the medium term.”
NH
The discussions began in October when Carlyle made an unsolicited
approach to Shanks with an indicative offer of 135p/share. In
December, when the Board announced the indicative bid, it said that an
offer of 150p/share or more “would deliver an appropriate value to
shareholders”.
approach to Shanks with an indicative offer of 135p/share. In
December, when the Board announced the indicative bid, it said that an
offer of 150p/share or more “would deliver an appropriate value to
shareholders”.
NH
This announcement will clearly disappoint investors, although given
Shanks’ current share price of 120p, risk of a lower or no bid has
already been partly discounted.
Shanks’ current share price of 120p, risk of a lower or no bid has
already been partly discounted.
NH
We expect the share price to be weak today although we would not
expect the shares to fall back to pre-talk levels at 90p. We continue to
believe that the company is well placed to benefit from the growth of
the pan-European waste market, and in particular the opportunities
from the UK PFI market and would not rule out medium term interest
from other parties. If the shares open very weak, we could see this as a
potential medium term buying opportunity.
expect the shares to fall back to pre-talk levels at 90p. We continue to
believe that the company is well placed to benefit from the growth of
the pan-European waste market, and in particular the opportunities
from the UK PFI market and would not rule out medium term interest
from other parties. If the shares open very weak, we could see this as a
potential medium term buying opportunity.
NH
The next scheduled newsflow will be its full year results on 20 May
although Shanks could provide an update on its sale of its equity stakes
in its UK PFI contracts in the interim.
although Shanks could provide an update on its sale of its equity stakes
in its UK PFI contracts in the interim.
NH
there you go
BE
Yeah – Goldman makes the same point on price
BE
We estimate that a price of 120p/share is equivalent to an EV/EBITDA
multiple of 6.5x, based on Reuters consensus EBITDA of £108 mn
(2009/10E). This is significantly below historical M&A multiples in the
sector (between 8x and 10x).
Shanks had previously indicated that it would be prepared to accept an
offer in the region of 150p/share, following Carlyle’s initial approach, which
was based on an indicative offer of 135p/share. We estimate that a price of
150p is equivalent to an EV/EBITDA multiple of 7.6x EV/EBITDA (2009/10E,
consensus).
multiple of 6.5x, based on Reuters consensus EBITDA of £108 mn
(2009/10E). This is significantly below historical M&A multiples in the
sector (between 8x and 10x).
Shanks had previously indicated that it would be prepared to accept an
offer in the region of 150p/share, following Carlyle’s initial approach, which
was based on an indicative offer of 135p/share. We estimate that a price of
150p is equivalent to an EV/EBITDA multiple of 7.6x EV/EBITDA (2009/10E,
consensus).
11:46AM
NH
market update
NH
FTSE 100 now off 42 points at 5,564
NH
and the GBK
BE
$1.4942
NH
moving on
NH
any of these results statements interesting?
BE
Bleh … well, Liberty’s break-up plan is not getting the reaction management would have hoped.
NH
but that’s more down to the results, though
NH
weaker than expected
BE
Yeah – NAV’s a bit light.
Liberty International PLC (LII:LSE): Last: 488.80, down 17.7 (-3.49%), High: 497.80, Low: 485.40, Volume: 2.61m
BE
And the split stuff had been very well flagged
NH
indeed
NH
two companies
NH
shopping centres
NH
and other stuff, mainly in London
BE
Yeah – with the London one looking an weird beast with legacy commitments to Great Portland and all sorts
NH
Right
NH
I have a note from Collins Stewart on this
NH
they say sell Liberty
NH
Full year results were announced this morning and NAV disappointed coming in at 464p. This is slightly below our estimate of 483p that we thought was on the bearish end of estimates. The reason is in line with our thesis for this stock in that their portfolio didn’t fall as much as its competitors during the downturn and is now not rebounding as hard (partly due to the lack of large lot size transactions). Their portfolio value only increased 2% in H2 2009. We were estimating a 4% increase but we expect the market was looking for more. EPS was broadly in line with expectation at 18.3p (our estimate was 19.9p). Dividend of 16.5p was exactly in line with expectation.
NH
Today’s disappointing NAV should see the stock to come off as a result toward our 419p price target. We reiterate our SELL recommendation in what remain challenging occupier markets. Liberty reported that nearly half of their shopping centre leasing deals have been completed on short term lettings where the rent shortfall is closer to 35%.
BE
And there’s a detailed piece from Harm Meijer at JP Morgan
BE
Who’s always worth reading
BE
Liberty Int: Weaker-than-expected results and demerger
confirmed. Liberty Int reported an Adj NAV of 464p vs. JPMe 503p
(-7.7%), Adj EPS of 18.3p vs. 17.6p and dividend of 16.5p (vs. JPMe
6.5p). Management makes a case for future yield compression by
pointing to the yield spread. We see future valuation gains indeed, but
the 5.7% initial yield on UK shopping centres (purchasers’ costs
included) does not strike us as very attractive. Separately, the company
confirmed the demerger plans today and while we were unable to find
costs associated with this, the proposal makes sense in our view.
Overall: we believe potential valuation gains and merger benefits are
largely priced in: UW.
confirmed. Liberty Int reported an Adj NAV of 464p vs. JPMe 503p
(-7.7%), Adj EPS of 18.3p vs. 17.6p and dividend of 16.5p (vs. JPMe
6.5p). Management makes a case for future yield compression by
pointing to the yield spread. We see future valuation gains indeed, but
the 5.7% initial yield on UK shopping centres (purchasers’ costs
included) does not strike us as very attractive. Separately, the company
confirmed the demerger plans today and while we were unable to find
costs associated with this, the proposal makes sense in our view.
Overall: we believe potential valuation gains and merger benefits are
largely priced in: UW.
BE
Operationally weaker. The shopping centre gross rental income fell by
6% over the year vs. JPMe -5%, while occupancy (incl. 1.5% under
offer) amounted to 97.8% vs. JPMe 98.5%. The better-than-expected
Adj EPS of 18.3p was the result of other income (insurance recovery of
£5m) and slightly lower overhead costs. New shopping centre lettings
were 20% below the last passing rent with short-term lets being 35%
lower. Failures in the shopping centre portfolio have reduced to 1% per
quarter.
6% over the year vs. JPMe -5%, while occupancy (incl. 1.5% under
offer) amounted to 97.8% vs. JPMe 98.5%. The better-than-expected
Adj EPS of 18.3p was the result of other income (insurance recovery of
£5m) and slightly lower overhead costs. New shopping centre lettings
were 20% below the last passing rent with short-term lets being 35%
lower. Failures in the shopping centre portfolio have reduced to 1% per
quarter.
BE
-10.6% revaluation. Liberty Int. published a revaluation of -10.6% over
2009, which was below our estimate of -6%. The UK shopping centre
portfolio dropped 10.4% in value, while Capital & Counties UK fell
7.8%. The US portfolio was significantly devalued by 20.8%, but the
company said it continues to explore a tax efficient solution to reduce
its US activities over time.
2009, which was below our estimate of -6%. The UK shopping centre
portfolio dropped 10.4% in value, while Capital & Counties UK fell
7.8%. The US portfolio was significantly devalued by 20.8%, but the
company said it continues to explore a tax efficient solution to reduce
its US activities over time.
NH
thanks for that
11:51AM
NH
More results
NH
John is asking about Inmarsat
NH
which have also filed results today
Inmarsat plc (ISAT:LSE): Last: 757.00, down 18 (-2.32%), High: 783.50, Low: 750.50, Volume: 599.76k
BE
BE
(in that it launches them, not the share price.)
NH
it looks to be in line
NH
stock off a little of profit taking
NH
quite pricey this stock
BE
Yeah – and the main disappointment seems to be there’s no upgrades to justify it.
NH
yep
NH
it’s one of those stories
NH
but not bad figures at all
NH
just no upgrades
NH
here’s JP Morgan Caz
NH
No new revenue guidance at this stage but full year dividend growth of
10%, 5% above expectations, provides a positive message in this respect.
Inmarsat has declared a 2nd interim dividend of 20.63 cents (+13%)
which will be paid in the current tax year.
10%, 5% above expectations, provides a positive message in this respect.
Inmarsat has declared a 2nd interim dividend of 20.63 cents (+13%)
which will be paid in the current tax year.
NH
Outlook: “We believe demand…….is continuing to expand…….we
believe the group can continue to deliver solid revenue growth in 2010”.
Group capex guidance of $160-170m for 2010 looks to be c. $20m higher
than our current estimate on an underlying basis. We do not expect to see
any further material estimate changes at this stage
believe the group can continue to deliver solid revenue growth in 2010”.
Group capex guidance of $160-170m for 2010 looks to be c. $20m higher
than our current estimate on an underlying basis. We do not expect to see
any further material estimate changes at this stage
NH
For 2010E, we estimate Inmarsat is trading on an EV/EBITDA of 10x, a
PER of 26x, an equity free cash flow yield of 7% with a normalised free
cash flow multiple of 18x and a 3.2% dividend yield. Given their recent
performance, some profit-taking is possible. However, we continue to
believe Inmarsat’s rating can be more than justified given its sustainable
growth and possible spectrum value. Inmarsat remains a geared play on
the US$ broadly with a 3:2 relationship in theory.
PER of 26x, an equity free cash flow yield of 7% with a normalised free
cash flow multiple of 18x and a 3.2% dividend yield. Given their recent
performance, some profit-taking is possible. However, we continue to
believe Inmarsat’s rating can be more than justified given its sustainable
growth and possible spectrum value. Inmarsat remains a geared play on
the US$ broadly with a 3:2 relationship in theory.
NH
so 26 times prospective
NH
but a big dollar earner
NH
and there is always the prospective of a takeover bid
BE
Well, quite. There’s ALWAYS the prospect of a takeover.
BE
Without there actually being a takeover.
BE
How long have we been waiting for that …. two years at least.
NH
one day
NH
it will happen
NH
Harbinger will swoop
NH
one day
BE
Hm. Wonder if we’ll be alive to see it.
NH

BE
Anyway, let’s push on.
11:56AM
NH
Just flcking through my notes
NH
for some other stuff to look at
NH
Imperial Tobacco
NH
being whacked by a UBS downgrade
BE
Okay … What’s the gist of that?
NH
valuation i think
NH
more interesting is a note that’s come out of Deutsche today
NH
on the anniversary of the market nadir
NH
their view is
NH
hang on
NH
will get it
NH
Positioning a key driver of market and sector performance since March lows. We have
emphasized previously the relative dearth of new flows into or out of equities since
the lows of last March. This has meant that the positioning of existing equity investors
(mutual funds and long-short equity hedge funds in particular) vis-à-vis the market and
across sectors has been a key driver of returns.
emphasized previously the relative dearth of new flows into or out of equities since
the lows of last March. This has meant that the positioning of existing equity investors
(mutual funds and long-short equity hedge funds in particular) vis-à-vis the market and
across sectors has been a key driver of returns.
NH
Anatomy of the correction: Net short in futures at all-time high. In terms of
fundamentals, following the relatively uninterrupted rally of 70% from the March lows,
there was a growing consensus for a correction (-10%). In the event, the sequence of
three shocks in quick succession (China tightening; Greece sovereign risk; and
Washington policy risk) trumped much-better-than-expected Q4 earnings, resulting in a
peak-to-trough 9% sell-off. We argued that the selldown was a temporary correction
and an economic recovery was far from being priced into US equities (US Equity
Strategy, What’s Working? February 10, 2010)
fundamentals, following the relatively uninterrupted rally of 70% from the March lows,
there was a growing consensus for a correction (-10%). In the event, the sequence of
three shocks in quick succession (China tightening; Greece sovereign risk; and
Washington policy risk) trumped much-better-than-expected Q4 earnings, resulting in a
peak-to-trough 9% sell-off. We argued that the selldown was a temporary correction
and an economic recovery was far from being priced into US equities (US Equity
Strategy, What’s Working? February 10, 2010)
NH
). In terms of flows and positioning, the
sell-down saw notable outflows from mutual funds (1.4% of AUM); mutual funds and
hedge funds reduced exposure to the market by 8 and 20 percentage points,
respectively; and most notably, the S&P 500 net futures short position increased by
~60k contracts, to an all-time high. The latter short was bigger than last March, which
saw the S&P fall 15% over the month
sell-down saw notable outflows from mutual funds (1.4% of AUM); mutual funds and
hedge funds reduced exposure to the market by 8 and 20 percentage points,
respectively; and most notably, the S&P 500 net futures short position increased by
~60k contracts, to an all-time high. The latter short was bigger than last March, which
saw the S&P fall 15% over the month
NH
The underweight positioning overhang remains. Equity flows turned modestly positive
over the last two weeks, but have further to recover in cumulative terms. Mutual fund
positioning turned up from underweight to neutral. However, long-short equity hedge
funds positioning remains more than 10 percentage points underweight relative to
November-December levels and 15- 20 pp below pre-financial crisis levels. Most
importantly, the record net short S&P 500 futures position as of Tuesday last week had
barely begun to be covered
over the last two weeks, but have further to recover in cumulative terms. Mutual fund
positioning turned up from underweight to neutral. However, long-short equity hedge
funds positioning remains more than 10 percentage points underweight relative to
November-December levels and 15- 20 pp below pre-financial crisis levels. Most
importantly, the record net short S&P 500 futures position as of Tuesday last week had
barely begun to be covered
NH
After the correction: Target 1250 on futures unwind by April payrolls. Our estimate of
the implications of an unwinding of the net futures short position to average levels is
S&P 500 upside to 1250. The key fundamental catalyst for the unwinding of positions
remains, in our view, a recovery in the labor market. We expect March payrolls will be
up a strong +350k (underlying recovery and a snowstorm snap-back) but the market
will likely only get more confident with a second increase in payrolls in April. Given Q4
2009 earnings of $77 at an annualized rate (ex-Tarp charges), 1250 would imply a
multiple of 16.2x on these earnings—in the vicinity of our estimate of fair value (16.4x)
the implications of an unwinding of the net futures short position to average levels is
S&P 500 upside to 1250. The key fundamental catalyst for the unwinding of positions
remains, in our view, a recovery in the labor market. We expect March payrolls will be
up a strong +350k (underlying recovery and a snowstorm snap-back) but the market
will likely only get more confident with a second increase in payrolls in April. Given Q4
2009 earnings of $77 at an annualized rate (ex-Tarp charges), 1250 would imply a
multiple of 16.2x on these earnings—in the vicinity of our estimate of fair value (16.4x)
NH
(Lawnmower – writen notes on a pad. Today’s show isn’t scripted. we ran out of time).
11:59AM
NH
Anything you want to add Bryce
BE
(In fact, none of the shows have a script any more. This is all seat of the pants stuff.)
BE
Well, we forgot to mention the BRC data.
NH
oh, i missed that
BE
Or at least, didn’t mention it.
BE
No surprises really.
BE
Snow.
BE
Feb sales up 2.2% on a same store basis, but against very soggy comps
BE
Cautious tone.
BE
But below the line, DIY looks very weak
NH
the UK economy is mush
BE
True.
BE
I’m wondering if Home Retail will be able to say anything bright in its upcoming results …
Home Retail Group plc (HOME:LSE): Last: 266.20, down 1.4 (-0.52%), High: 270.50, Low: 266.20, Volume: 2.44m
NH
well
NH
it might be able to sell Homebase to BestBuy
NH
that would be positive
NH
other than that
NH
they will get murdered by the cab;e rate
BE
Hm. For avoidance of doubt, we should emphasise that the Homebase suggestion is extremely raw.
BE
Meanwhile, before we close …
NH
it is
NH
but not without some merit
BE
Hm.
BE
Meanwhile
BE
Reckitt Benckiser is small up
Reckitt Benckiser Group Plc (RB.:LSE): Last: 3,516, no change, High: 3,540, Low: 3,515, Volume: 567.30k
BE
Actually, flat now.
BE
Anyway, they had a big investor conference thing yesterday.
NH
and
BE
The most interesting bit was cash generation
NH
where they talking about that skag drug they have
BE
Still no generic skag on the horizon apparently.
NH
a shame
BE
But back to the cash generation – the general tone seemed to be hinting at a return to shareholders.
NH
not a huge acquisition then
NH
of someone like Colgate
BE
Well, that would be option two I guess.
BE
Here’s … er … hang on … I’ve forgotten which broker sent this …
BE
Oh – Bryan Garnier
BE
Cash Generation is “like no other” and Capex requirements are low –
audience not so aware of this. Capex requirements are limited (around £100m
per annum) and with utilization capacity at around 50% allowing for huge
internal expansion without a need for further investment. Cash conversion is
“like nothing else in the peer group” according to CFO Colin Day. Cash
conversion is constantly above 100% of adjusted operating profit. Net working
capital should stay around -16% of sales. £200m net cash (FY09) allows for
significant return to shareholders. Dividend now at 50% payout ratio, but also
allows for special dividend and share buy-back for cancellation.
audience not so aware of this. Capex requirements are limited (around £100m
per annum) and with utilization capacity at around 50% allowing for huge
internal expansion without a need for further investment. Cash conversion is
“like nothing else in the peer group” according to CFO Colin Day. Cash
conversion is constantly above 100% of adjusted operating profit. Net working
capital should stay around -16% of sales. £200m net cash (FY09) allows for
significant return to shareholders. Dividend now at 50% payout ratio, but also
allows for special dividend and share buy-back for cancellation.
BE
And finally, Logica’s getting a push from Evo
Logica Plc (LOG:LSE): Last: 123.50, up 3.2 (+2.66%), High: 124.20, Low: 121.10, Volume: 7.34m
BE
With a c8% 2010 FCF yield and cyclical lead indicators starting to turn
positive in 4Q09, we upgrade Logica from Neutral to Buy with a new price
target of 150p. The shares trade at a discount to historic norms and to
the Euro peer group.
positive in 4Q09, we upgrade Logica from Neutral to Buy with a new price
target of 150p. The shares trade at a discount to historic norms and to
the Euro peer group.
BE
That’s the upshot of that one.
BE
That’s me done. What about you Neil?
BE
Anything minnow?
NH
a couple of small cap things
NH
Delta
Delta PLC (DLTA:LSE): Last: 190.25, down 1 (-0.52%), High: 192.00, Low: 190.25, Volume: 2.62m
BE
Ah.
NH
Crystal Amber has bought more stock
NH
above the Valmont offer price of 185p a share
NH
a further 350,000 shares at 1.918, lifting holding to 3.55%.
NH
and remember the secret millionaire?
BE
Of course. That guy with the stables and the hat.
NH
yep the one who has mortgaged everything he has got against a company called Eatonfield
NH
well
NH
there is some good news
NH
well sort of
NH
raised £100,000 at 1p
NH
which gives the company
NH
enough cash until the end of March
NH
still needs to find another £1.1m
NH
to unlock the potential of the company
BE
Yes, but he never gives up.
NH
indeed
BE
He says so here
NH
Okay
NH
that’s it
NH
I have a lunch to get to
NH
with some brokers
NH
the FTSE 100 is down 38 points at 5,568
NH
and cable is $1.4966
NH
right
NH
that’s it from me
BE
And from me.
BE
Good afternoon everyone.
NH
thanks for logging in
NH
and see you all tomorrow
NH
bye
