Print

Markets live transcript 25 Nov 2009

Markets live chat transcript for the chat ending at 12:09 on 25 Nov 2009. Participants in this chat were: Neil Hume, FT (NH) Miles Johnson, FT (MJ) Bryce Elder (BE)

NH:
Good morning
NH:
bonjour
NH:
hola
NH:
It’s 11.03am
NH:
and time for Markets Live
NH:
FT Alphaville’s daily trawl round the market
NH:
right
NH:
who is here with me today
NH:
looks like Miles
MJ:
Morning all
MJ:
Good to be here
NH:
back in the hot seat
MJ:
Right
MJ:
Lots of rumours this morning
NH:
yeah there’s been a bit of an outbreak
MJ:
RAW infestation
RAW is market chatter – information that has not been formally tested through traditional journalistic channels (PRs etc). The story might be complete rubbish, but if we believe there is some substance to it we will say so. Either way, Reader Beware.
NH:
RAW, RAW, RAW everywhere
MJ:
So Neil, what are you hearing
MJ:
?
11:05AM
NH:
well
NH:
there’s International Power obviously
MJ:
That one is really being dragged out no?
NH:
it is
NH:
has there been any comment from GDF yet?
NH:
usually the French are quick to shoot down this stuff
MJ:
Erm, no
NH:
as I know only too well
NH:
the rumour if you missed it
NH:
is that GDF Suez looking at International Power
MJ:
seeking permission from the French govt to bid, if you believe some reports
NH:
Hmmm
NH:
I have not followed GDF too closely
NH:
too French
NH:
and too much politics
NH:
but from what I have read it seems to make a bit of sense
NH:
and GDF could pay up to 385p a share
NH:
got this from Merrill Lynch earlier this morning
NH:
The UK press is mentioning the possibility for GDF to bid on IPR. According to
the articles, GDF is talking to the French government about the option to launch
an offer prior to year end (Daily Mail and The Times).
We have always argued that the fit between GDF (Ex Tractebel) and IPR portfolio
was excellent. In the US, both groups are exposed to the same states, in the
Middle East both have a strong exposure to IPP projects and in the UK IPR’s
generation assets would fit GDF new ambitions to enter the UK power market.
Only the Australian and Pakistani assets would not fit with the GDF portfolio in
our view.
NH:
GDF has the balance sheet to make such a move. Assuming an offer with a 40%
premium (385p), the total cost would be £11bn (including debt), or €12bn.
Considering EBITDA forecasts of £1.22bn for next year, that would put GDF
leverage to 2.5x compared to 2x now. Even with such a big premium and pre
synergies we estimate the deal would EPS accretive by about 7% in 2010.
We think such a deal makes sense from both a strategic and financial standpoint
and see potential operational synergies between the two companies.
MJ:
any more comment?
NH:
not at the minute
NH:
IPR does not seem to be that widely followed
MJ:
Is it a bit boring I suppose
NH:
or all the analysts are covering the results from Unitied Utilities this morning
MJ:
That too
MJ:
of course
MJ:
what needs to be pointed out here
MJ:
is that the Takeover Panel would have by now contacted GDF and its advisors
MJ:
to see if there is anything in this story
MJ:
and the fact that they have said anything
MJ:
means if this bid is happening
MJ:
it is at a very early stage
NH:
fair point
NH:
but no smoke without fire and all that
MJ:
True – this is the story that will not die
MJ:
What are the shares doing?
NH:
hang on. Off the top by the looks of things
NH:
hit 289.4p
NH:
earlier today
NH:
now up just 10.4p at 286p
11:10AM
MJ:
Any more RAW?
NH:
before we go there
NH:
a joke
NH:
a football joke
NH:
Chelsea have Chelsea TV
NH:
Man UTD have Man U TV
NH:
and Liverpool
NH:
have the history channel
MJ:
boom boom
NH:
and what’s the wider market doing?
MJ:
We are up
MJ:
FTSE 100 23 points higher at 5347
MJ:
Fed comments, commodities etc
NH:
same old, same old then
NH:
and one more thing
NH:
before we go back to the RAW
NH:
the Varsity Comp
MJ:
Ah yes
NH:
Nomura and biking the tickets over now
NH:
and the results
NH:
announced yesterday
NH:
still stand
NH:
the stewards found nothing wrong in the first abitary decision
NH:
even if the maths was a bit wonky
11:12AM
MJ:
Moving on
MJ:
Some action in the gambling sector this morning
NH:
yes
NH:
speculation this morning that Opap of Greece is running the slide rule over either Ladbrokes or William Hill
MJ:
yeah
MJ:
was looking at Opap earlier
MJ:
or to give the company its full name
MJ:
the Greek Organisation of Football Prognostics
NH:
MJ:
actually it is quite big
MJ:
listed on the Athens exchange
MJ:
market cap around $7.7bn
MJ:
think it was the former state lottery
NH:
right
NH:
I am sure this story has done the rounds before
NH:
sure of it
NH:
and William Hill has shown interest in Greece before
NH:
this from a couple of years ago
NH:
William Hill is testing the odds on the Greek government relaxing restrictions on gambling by applying for a licence to run betting shops in its country.
The move is the latest in a series of challenges by UK bookmakers to state-run monopolies in continental Europe that are feeling the heat of the European Commission’s drive to liberalise gambling markets.
Greece has one of the biggest gambling markets in Europe after the UK, Spain and Italy, though it is not included in the list of EU countries facing legal action from the commission over restrictions on access to gambling markets.
But William Hill’s applications to open betting shops and run bookmaking are likely to test the government’s determination to keep the state monopoly deal with Opap, which is publicly listed.
MJ:
Not sure what to make of this
MJ:
But bankers say it comes around every couple of weeks
NH:
I am a bit puzzled too
MJ:
Is there any share price reaction?
NH:
hang on
Ladbrokes (LAD:LSE): Last: 132.90, up 1.6 (+1.22%), High: 134.70, Low: 132.10, Volume: 3.07m
William Hill (WMH:LSE): Last: 187.40, up 3.3 (+1.79%), High: 189.70, Low: 184.40, Volume: 947.19k
MJ:
Hmm, modest gains
11:17AM
NH:
actually I have a funny story about William Hill
NH:
they are based in North London right
MJ:
yeah, Wood Green right?
NH:
well BarCap went to see them the other day
NH:
to pitch something or other, possibly for the brokership
NH:
anyway
NH:
Hill’s didn’t have a meeting room
NH:
so
NH:
they all had to troop down to the Barclays branch
NH:
on Wood Green high street
MJ:
Nice
NH:
now given the reputation of that area
NH:
presumably it is heavily fortified
NH:
anyway
NH:
the idea of all these highly paid financiers wandering around Wood Green
NH:
trying to find the Barclays branch
NH:
and then holding a meeting with the cashiers
NH:
or the mortgage adivsor made me laught
MJ:
They probably thought they were taking their lives into their own hands
NH:
indeed
NH:
dangerous place Wood Green
NH:
fortuanately my train does not stop there
NH:
is just steams through
11:20AM
MJ:
Any more RAW?
NH:
a couple more bits
NH:
Care Uk
NH:
nursing home operator
NH:
rubuffed a bid from Bridgepoint in the summer
NH:
talk this morning that they could come back with a higher offer
NH:
and
NH:
that KKR are also sniffing around and could bid
Care UK (CUK:LSE): Last: 367.00, up 2 (+0.55%), High: 367.00, Low: 348.00, Volume: 5.25k
MJ:
And the other one?
NH:
Rentokil
NH:
rumours of a big announcement later this week
NH:
one theory seems to be
NH:
that they could announce the sale of their parcel business
NH:
CityLink
MJ:
That meant to be a bit of a dog isn’t it? Who would buy that?
NH:
no idea
NH:
private equity
NH:
not sure
NH:
sound a bit of a long shot
NH:
but if they did sell it
NH:
it would probably go down rather well
MJ:
Share price?
NH:
one moment
NH:
they are actually quite good
Rentokil Initial (RTO:LSE): Last: 103.30, up 2.4 (+2.38%), High: 103.40, Low: 101.50, Volume: 2.66m
MJ:
Wow.That was a freight train of RAW.
MJ:
FT AV
MJ:
helping in the efficient allocation of market rumour since 2006
NH:
well
NH:
trying to
11:25AM
MJ:
So where now?
NH:
er the GDP data?
MJ:
Well, if we have to
MJ:
Not much to see there
NH:
I think we do
MJ:
Dismal scientists are cheery this morning though
MJ:
Revised third quarter UK GDP data was revised to a 0.3 per cent contraction
MJ:
verses the first reading of 0.4 per cent
MJ:
The prolific Howard Archer, for one, is pleased
MJ:
The good news is that UK GDP contracted modestly less than previously estimated in the third quarter. This is also good news for we economists as it means we were slightly less wrong in our forecasts of a return to growth.
The bad news is that the data still show the economy in recession in the third quarter and so we economists were still wrong
But we will be right in our forecasts that the economy will finally return to growth in the fourth quarter!
NH:
Doesn’t change the UK’s growing reputation as the sick man of major economies much.
NH:
or that fact that most economists were still way out
MJ:
Indeed
MJ:
Hard to put a positive spin on six consecutive quarters of economic contraction.
MJ:
Anyway, not wanting to dwell on this for too long
MJ:
here is a note from Barclays Capital’s Simon Hayes
MJ:
UK Q3 GDP revised up slightly, surprise stabilisation in private demand

The second estimate of Q3 GDP growth was -0.3% q/q, a slight upward revision from the preliminary estimate of -0.4%. Lying behind this, a small upward revision to services output more than offset a small downward revision to industrial production. Although there has been a furious debate about the validity of the preliminary estimate, the official picture remains one of sustained weakness in economic activity with GDP dropping in six consecutive quarters, the longest recession on record. We do, however, expect the UK to emerge from recession in Q4.

More interesting than the headline number is the estimated composition of growth in Q3. In recent months the MPC has expressed concern about private domestic demand – household consumption and private investment – which had both fallen at their fastest pace on record during this recession. A stabilisation in private domestic demand was seen as a prerequisite for declaring an end to the economic crisis.

MJ:
Today’s release shows that household consumption was flat q/q while investment is estimated to have fallen by just 0.3% q/q (although a caveat here is that we will not know until next month’s third GDP estimate how much of this is down to government investment). Both were stronger than the consensus (and our own) forecasts and this earlier-than-expected stabilisation in private domestic spending is encouraging news.

The corollary, however, is that other components of demand were weaker than expected. In particular, exports grew by just 0.5% q/q compared with a 1.3% q/q rise in imports, meaning that net trade subtracted 0.2pp from GDP growth following six consecutive quarters of positive contributions. Government spending was also weak, rising by just 0.2% q/q. This continues a recent pattern of government demand undershooting the Treasury’s Budget forecasts.

Some commentators have worried that growth is being boosted by stockbuilding, which would inevitably prove to be temporary. However, today’s release shows that stockbuilding made a zero contribution to growth in Q3, less than the 0.3pp contribution made in Q2 – although we would caution that stockbuilding is a residual item at this stage in the data production process and is prone to heavy revision.

Given the stabilisation in private domestic demand in Q3, the stage is set for the economy to register positive growth in Q4. The two flies in the ointment are net trade and government spending. The negative net trade contribution in Q3 may prove to be erratic, due in part to strong vehicle imports tied to the government’s car scrappage scheme. The weakness in government consumption relative to the Budget projections is more perplexing, but may reflect an unwillingness on the part of government departments to expand spending given the looming need for fiscal consolidation.

NH:
Thanks for that
11:27AM
MJ:
Now were though with that…
NH:
what about Monkey’s UBSOTD
MJ:
Good idea
MJ:
Sports Direct wasn;t it?
NH:
er yes
NH:
sorry
NH:
we got forgot to mention the GBK
NH:
with the GDP data
NH:
cable is $1.6706
NH:
and a euro buys 90p
NH:
dollar looks rubbish though
NH:
against the euro
NH:
1.5040
NH:
anyway
NH:
Sports Direct
NH:
Monkey was referring to this
NH:
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/newsbysector/retailandconsumer/6646704/Tesco-demands-refund-after-paying-nearly-1m-for-six-bikes.html
NH:
Tesco is taking a subsidiary of Mike Ashley’s Sports Direct to court in a bizarre case involving half a dozen bicycles and almost £1m.

Britain’s biggest retailer has launched a legal action against Universal Cycles amid claims that a member of the supermarket chain’s finance team mistakenly paid £984,000 for six bicycles.

Tesco claims it should have paid £984 for the Muddy Fox Suspension Bikes and is seeking restitution of the overpaid monies, according to a legal action filed at the High Court.

MJ:
That is a UBSTOD
NH:
anyway that got me thinking
NH:
Sports Direct have a new chairman right
MJ:
the ex-drug Tsar, Keith Hellawell QMP
NH:
or to give him his other name
NH:
Black Night
MJ:
eh? remind me of the story behind that again
NH:
Once dubbed the Black Night for dressing entirely in black and driving a black Porsche, Hellawell sent shockwaves through the force as he set about reforming “outdated” attitudes.

MJ:
Makes him sound a bit like a superhero
NH:
it does
NH:
and will need those powers
NH:
are Sports Direct
MJ:
(Vintage, should have been QPM – Queen’s Police Medal)
NH:
So
NH:
I think we should make a market in how long Hellawell stays in the job
NH:
How long can the ex-copper work with mad Mike Ashley?
MJ:
Hmmm
MJ:
a year?
NH:
here’s my spread
NH:
270-300 days
NH:
Buy or sell
NH:
you decide
MJ:
well, it can’t last
MJ:
seems bound to end in disaster
MJ:
but I think Keith is a bit of tough guy
MJ:
and he will tough it out for a year at least
NH:
remember though that Sports Direct is facing SFO and OFT investigations
MJ:
sure
MJ:
but Keith saw off one of those when he was at Goldshield
NH:
he did
Sports Direct International (SPD:LSE): Last: 97.50, up 0.5 (+0.52%), High: 98.95, Low: 96.50, Volume: 90.68k
NH:
and yes
NH:
the black night was discovered by TL
NH:
well done
11:34AM
MJ:
Right, all takers should contact Neil
MJ:
Anyway
MJ:
A spot of Cadbury-watch?
NH:
good idea
NH:
lots of foreign press stories today
MJ:
Seems to be a bit of demand from the ROTR for an update
NH:
Right, this is from the New York Post
NH:
Hershey, Ferrero eye Cadbury split
By JOSH KOSMAN
Last Updated: 1:42 AM, November 25, 2009
NH:
Hershey wants the chocolate and Ferrero wants the chewing gum.
Details of the talks between the two candy makers are starting to
emerge, as they work out how they would slice up Cadbury in a roughly
$17 billion takeover. The pace of negotiations has not changed despite
reports last weekend that Hershey could buy Cadbury on its own, instead
of partnering with Ferrero against Kraft’s $16 billion bid. Hershey
wants as much of Cadbury as it can afford, including its slow-growth UK
chocolate business, a source close to the process said.

Ferrero, with Western Europe’s largest chocolate confectionery market
share, is proposing taking the faster-growing chewing gum and candy
lines and other assets that make up 40 percent of Cadbury.

NH:
this is from
NH:
Milano Finanz
NH:
Article notes the Kraft exlusivity agreement with its funding banks and
says this could be part of the reason behind Hershey speaking to Ferrero
about a combined bid for CBRY – Italian banks would play a major role in
any bid. Article also discusses difficulty for Nestle to bid given
antitrust issues. Article attached.
NH:
and Il Sole
NH:
Article says that it could be the week for Nestle to make its move on
CBRY, citing sources in London. Rumours are circulating that Nestle is
working on the structure of an offer that could be made within days.
Nestle has two options the paper says – Go it alone for CBRY, or team up
with Hershey – the latter would be less problematic, especially
regarding antitrust issues. The paper claims Kraft has the funding ready
to raise its offer should Nestle make a move. Paper adds that Hershey
could be keen to do an alliance with Ferrero given the Italian group’s
access to funds. Talks between Hershey and Ferrero are continuing every
day by telephone, in expectation of a face to face meeting in Italy.
Ferrero has hired Allen & Overy as well as Rothschild and Mediobanca.
MJ:
(No Rain, we are still waiting for our Kinder goodie bag)
NH:
and nothing from Hershey, either
NH:
although
NH:
I did find a Hershey bar in the local newsagent
NH:
cookies and cream
NH:
Tracy liked it
NH:
i thought it was awful
NH:
and really thin too
NH:
like a wafer
MJ:
I personally cannot stomach hershey
NH:
anyway
NH:
Cadbury share price
MJ:
we digress
MJ:
Down 1p at 807p
NH:
fjp73 brings up an interesting point
NH:
Miles has been looking at this
MJ:
Yeah
MJ:
Now I havent seen the agreement myself
MJ:
But I gather it is standard practice that it would cover both lending, and advisory work for the banks involved – the leads at least
MJ:
would be very strange if it didnt anyway
MJ:
But JPM and BoA have big enough balance sheets to fund hershey
NH:
that’s true
NH:
and Fererro
NH:
have the Italian banks
NH:
Unicredit
MJ:
Mediobanca of course
NH:
and Intesa
MJ:
and Intese SanPaulo
MJ:
Dont know much about them though personally
MJ:
Or what weight they can pull financing-wise
NH:
thanks for that
11:41AM
NH:
Okay
NH:
Bryce would like to join the chat
NH:
on Rentokil
NH:
he has been making a few calls
NH:
what have you managed to discover
BE:
Hello all
MJ:
Hi bryce
BE:
Right – the story over the past few days has been about potential disposals
NH:
sure
BE:
With the parcels business thought to be the most likely bit to go
NH:
but
NH:
is there a buyer out there
NH:
and do RTO want to sell?
BE:
Yes. And no.
BE:
That’s the theory anyway.
BE:
The suggestion I’ve had is that private equity has had a look at City Link, both recently and many many times in the past
NH:
right
BE:
But management – who were doing an institutional tour last week, as it happens – see the turnaround of this business as totemic
BE:
And it looks to be heading towards profitability by the end of the year
NH:
hmmm
NH:
if they could manage that
NH:
a turnaround that is
NH:
it would drive the share price up
NH:
and then the new management team
NH:
could cash in on that huge
NH:
incentive scheme
BE:
Yeah, precisely. That’s the talk anyway.
BE:
However, that doesn’t mean disposals are totally off the agenda.
NH:
(bohemia, thanks. )
BE:
If they could sell the laundry business, for example, they’d probably take the buyer’s hand off at the wristwatch
NH:
BE:
Finding a buyer is the tricky bit though.
NH:
thanks very much for all that
MJ:
Thanks for that
NH:
RTO price still holding
Rentokil Initial (RTO:LSE): Last: 104.00, up 3.1 (+3.07%), High: 104.00, Low: 101.50, Volume: 3.15m
BE:
Hang on – while I’m here …
BE:
We were snide about Emblaze’s product launch yesterday.
NH:
yes
NH:
you were horrible to them
Emblaze (BLZ:LSE): Last: 52.25, down 0.5 (-0.95%), High: 53.00, Low: 51.00, Volume: 147.07k
BE:
Horrible is just my way.
BE:
However, it appears this thing has impressed the geeks.
BE:
For example
BE:
Whether that means it’s commercial, who knows?
NH:
what is it?
NH:
a smart phone
BE:
Yeah – with a whizzy menu thing designed for right-handed people
BE:
Which leaves me screwed, but that’s by the by
BE:
And whether it’s commercial is the big question. Tough market, handsets.
NH:
yes, what edge have Emblaze got?
BE:
Good question.
BE:
No distribution, no manufacturing, no brand ………
BE:
Anyway, thanks for allowing me to crash in. Do carry on.
NH:
thanks bryce
11:49AM
NH:
Right
NH:
back to IPR for one moment
NH:
I have some more comment on the bid rumours
NH:
this from a sector watcher
NH:
GDF Suez has always been thought of as potential bidder, but has been put out of the frame in recent years because of the GDF/Suez merger and integration.
NH:
Other large players are very likely running the rule over IPR.
NH:
At this share price, IPR is a natural break-up target.
NH:
GDF Suez:
– UK would be a very attractive platform (First Hydro – jewel in crown- and mixed gas and coal assets) for anyone wanting to enter the UK, like GDF Suez.
– Middle East and Asia – GDF Suez compete with IPR here. IPR has a very strong presence in Middle East and GDF Suez is probably their key competitor.
- US assets – GDF Suez has a strong presence. Centrica would also be a natural buyer.
NH:
Other areas:
– Australia. Once CO2 legislation is passed, you can start getting a lower risk valuation of the assets and incumbents could be interested, although there would be competition issues.

– Europe is a potpourri. The Belgian and Portuguese plant all have long term PPAs and GDF Suez would be interested in running them. The ISAB plant in Italy has just come out of the lucrative period of “renewable” pricing and ERG (site owners) would probably buy. The German and Italian wind assets could be of interests to institutional buyers, although GDF Suez may keep them (although I personally would not touch Italian wind with a barge pole – flaky regulatory regime).

NH:
The current market view of IPR is an EPS momentum, growth play with 40% payout. A major reason for the price weakness in recent months has has been caused by faltering EPS expectations (significantly down in down in 2010 due to Czech assets sales) and poor US performance. We believe IPR is no longer a growth play, with limited opportunities in merchant markets. We believe IPR needs to reposition itself as a yield play. It needs to say it has no further merchant growth aspirations, boost DPS payout to 50% in 2010, maintaining DPS growth, which it can easily do, due to its strong cash flow. We believe that the company will be drawn inexorably to the same conclusions as us (at least on payout), and have boosted our payout ratio assumption to 50%, despite current policy being 40%.
NH:
t looks like IPR to survive needs to do this sooner rather than later.
MJ:
Thanks for that
11:51AM
NH:
Where now?
MJ:
Well, there was a great story from our media team
MJ:
about the BBC looking into floating BBC Worldwide.
MJ:
Has a bit of everything this story
MJ:
Political manoeuvring ahead of the election, post-crunch privatisation
MJ:
deal action
MJ:
And the meedja angle of course as well
MJ:
For those who haven’t seen Ben Fenton and Salamander Davoudi’s scoop
MJ:
Here is a bit
MJ:
The BBC has been holding discussions with City advisers about floating part of BBC Worldwide, its commercial arm, in response to pressure from the government and commercial rivals to dilute its media market power.
As Sir Michael Lyons, chairman of the BBC Trust, told the Financial Times on Tuesday that he had “an open mind” about the future ownership of Worldwide, people with knowledge of the matter said a partial flotation was one of several possible outcomes, including no change to its status.
Bankers say Worldwide is an attractive business and have estimated its total equity value at up to £2bn.
Worldwide, which operates 23 television channels in more than 100 countries and sells BBC branded magazines, Lonely Planet travel guides, merchandise and programme formats, had revenues of £1bn in 2008-09 and an operating profit of £112m before exceptional costs.
Two people close to the early-stage discussions told the Financial Times that Goldman Sachs and Credit Suisse were part of the advisory process. The banks declined to comment. Two other people close to the BBC confirmed that any flotation was unlikely before the end of 2010 at the earliest.
NH:
Very interesting.
MJ:
These privatisation pitches are of course very prestigious for the bankers
MJ:
Lots of manic pitching I imagine
MJ:
There have been gossip about invitations for pitches for privatisations being sent out. Not sure what they are though
NH:
Kingman going to Rothchild won’t do them any harm I imagine.
MJ:
Indeed. Valuable man to have around in these times
MJ:
Anyway, one of many to come, I think it is safe to say
11:53AM
NH:
Right
NH:
a few other things to look at
NH:
somoe people asking about Compass
NH:
the contract caterer
MJ:
Biggest riser in the FTSE 100
MJ:
Up 27.5p at 429p
NH:
hmm
NH:
annual results out today
NH:
and they look good
NH:
ahead of expectations
NH:
and a decent outlook statement
NH:
I have some comment
NH:
if people want it
NH:
this is from Caz
NH:
Overall, this is a solid set of results, 2% ahead of our expectations at the EPS level and 6% ahead of Reuters consensus. In addition, the outlook is confident, highlighting a strong pipeline of new business, “considerable potential to deliver ongoing cost efficiencies”, an expectation of further margin progress, and broadly flat revenue growth in 2010. This expectation is broadly consistent with Sodexo’s implicit organic revenue growth guidance in its Food and FM business (On-site Service Solutions) for 2010E of c. -0.5%, and Aramark’s comments at its Q4 results that it expects to return to organic growth in H2 2010E, following strong comparatives in H1.
NH:
We believe that Compass’ management’s confidence in achieving further EBIT margin progression in 2010E is significant (we forecast c. +10bps): in our view margin progression suggests limited EPS sensitivity to small changes in the organic revenue growth assumption for Compass, and therefore a high level of confidence in estimates. We continue to believe that Compass Group has a compelling investment case given our forecast of further EBIT margin expansion and 7% EPS growth in 2010E, and an acceleration in EPS growth in the medium term as it benefits from both strong structural growth and a cyclical upswing (44% of revenues are generated in the Business & Industry division). Compass trades on a September 2010E PER of 12.9x compared with Sodexo [EXHO.PA, SW FP, N/R, €37.33] on a 2010E PER of 15.1x (Reuters consensus).
MJ:
LYO – that is a yellow I’m afraid
NH:
and here’s
NH:
Collins Stewart
NH:
Strong results; c.2% ahead of pre-close guidance
Revenues increased 17.5% to £13.4bn, with organic growth flat. Underlying EBITA (including associates) was £884m, slightly ahead of our expectation of £866m. EPS rose 36% (15% at constant FX) to 30.0p, benefiting from a slightly lower than expected tax rate (28%) and a better interest charge performance.
■ Organic growth headwinds for at least the next six months
Organic sales growth moved from +2.5% in H1 to c.-2.5% in H2. The key driver of this has been the decline in the like-for-like volumes that have deteriorated from +1% in Q1 to -5% in Q3 and -6% in Q4. Contract retention has also deteriorated owing to a higher level of client site closures. Management expects a “broadly flat” (i.e could be negative) organic growth performance in FY10 (previously “our working assumption is flat organic growth”), though it will clearly be negative in 1H10. Over the medium-term management believes that a return to 6% organic sales growth is possible.
NH:
Pace of margin improvement to slow from here
The operating margin improved 70bp (60bp underlying) to 6.5%, and has increased by an impressive 200bp over the last three years. Management expects further improvement (highlighting opportunities in unit overheads). However, against a flat sales performance this will be more difficult to achieve; consensus is already discounting 20-30bp of increase in FY10 and over the medium-term we believe it will be challenging to achieve more than 7% at the Group level owing to the relatively low capital intensity of the business.
■ Strong cash generation. Medium-tem acquisitions likely
Free Cash Flow rose 14% to £593m. The strong cash generation, together with a steady improvement in asset utilisation has driven CFROC to 7.5% and CFROA to 22%, both decade highs. With acquisition spend likely to pick-up, further increases in returns are likely to be more muted.
■ Not expensive but better value elsewhere. Downgrade to HOLD
We have upgraded our EPS forecasts by c.4-5% reflecting lower interest charges. But we see better value in G4S and Mitie Group.
11:56AM
NH:
Right a bit of small cap corner
NH:
to finish with
NH:
what is going on with the GKP share price??
Gulf Keystone Petroleum (GKP:LSE): Last: 89.50, down 5.75 (-6.04%), High: 99.50, Low: 89.50, Volume: 2.85m
MJ:
Ooh – looking ugly. fallen pretty far since the drilling report
NH:
(Monkey – that’s straight red. Off. Early shower for you).
NH:
it is
NH:
the latest rumour
NH:
is that the company
NH:
are doing some pre-marketing for a cash call
NH:
and given
MJ:
NH:
that there is no new drilling news to come for a while now
NH:
they need to move quickly
NH:
there was also a negative note from Evo yesterday
NH:
EVO TAKE – While Shaikan-1 has continued to surprise on the upside, the drilling is now complete and we do not see material upside until Shaikan 2 starts in mid 2010. Switch to Sterling Energy where drilling on Sangaw North starts soon.
DETAILS – The light oil and higher pressure in the Triassic in Shaikan-1 is a positive sign. The DST’s to date have been encouraging with the company indicating total well potential of >30,000 b/d. There may be even deeper potential, but the well has now reached TD and we do not expect major positive newsflow until mid 2010.
VALUATION AND RECOMMENDATION – Our valuation of the reserves in Kurdistan is conservative and we still risk the chance of success at 50%. Based on the largest oil in place number revealed to date (5.3bn) and a 33% recovery factor we arrive at a risked value of Shaikan of 86p/share and 93p/share for the whole company. Therefore, with no material drilling newsflow until Shaikan 2 (mid 2010) we recommend switching into Sterling Energy (SEY), which is to start drilling on the Sangaw North prospect before year end.
MJ:
And the other Kurdish oil play, Heritage, is getting hit for six as well
NH:
it is
NH:
that hasn’t rallied since Monday’s brilliant deal in Uganda
NH:
look at it
Heritage Oil (HOIL:LSE): Last: 452.60, down 14.5 (-3.10%), High: 473.80, Low: 445.70, Volume: 985.68k
NH:
it looks very sick
NH:
are there some distressed CFD sellers around?
MJ:
(DD – lets not lower the tone)
MJ:
Very possibly
NH:
also told
NH:
this announcement
NH:
from City stockbroker Cenkos is interesting
NH:
Jim Durkin | Executive Director
Jim joined the Group as head of the corporate broking team in March 2005 and was appointed Executive Director in October 2006. He has over 20 years’ experience in the UK securities industry. Prior to joining the Group, Jim worked at Collins Stewart. He has worked extensively on the origination and execution of corporate finance transactions across a range of industries including insurance, property, financials and utilities.
NH:
now Dirkhim formed part of the SAS
NH:
with a guy called Paul Hodges
NH:
when they were at Collins Stewart
NH:
they dreamt up the acclerated IPO
NH:
this morning’s statement is a bit terse
NH:
and suggests there may have been a falling out
NH:
Cenkos Securities PLC announces that today Jimmy Durkin has left the Board of
the Company.
MJ:
Err. Is that it?
NH:
no
NH:
Enquiries:
Andrew Stewart, Executive Deputy Chairman, Cenkos 020 7397 8900
NH:
and a PR number
NH:
but that is it
MJ:
I see
MJ:
But he’s only left the board of the company
MJ:
Does that mean he has left the whole place?
NH:
not sure
MJ:
(DD – light touch regulation appears to work in this instance)
NH:
right
NH:
we must bring things to a close
NH:
before we
NH:
do
NH:
more rights issue rumours around in Resolution
MJ:
They are down at the moment
MJ:
down 3.5p at 85.3p
NH:
the market seems to think they are after Legal & General
NH:
i’m not so sure
NH:
I think they want an asset management business
NH:
a pure one
NH:
and they will need a cash call for it
NH:
not sure if the deal will happen in the UK
NH:
or Europe
NH:
anyway
NH:
are we done?
MJ:
I think we are
NH:
oh
NH:
and a Cenkos share price
MJ:
These compass gags have got to stop
NH:
down 2p at 148p
MJ:
Neil is ready to go beserk with the zapper
MJ:
Bryce is holding him back
MJ:
Going on a massacre
MJ:
I think I am getting out of here before things get ugly
NH:
I can’t keep up with the puns
NH:
there’s too many of them
NH:
like a computer game
MJ:
You need back up -where is Murph?
NH:
help
NH:
that’s it
NH:
not alternative
NH:
but to close things
NH:
and perhaps ban a few people
MJ:
Thanks for comments, but not for the puns
MJ:
only kidding
MJ:
Bye
NH:
cya
Print