This is quite astonishing.
The FSA fined UBS £8m on Thursday for failing to prevent employees carrying out unauthorised transactions with customer money in their wealth management division.
According to the press release, control failures at the bank between 2006 and 2007 enabled four employees to use client money to take unauthorised positions in foreign exchange and precious metals. The FSA was drawn to the matter by a whistle blower.
Here’s the press release (emphasis FT Alphaville’s):
The Financial Services Authority (FSA) today fined UBS AG (UBS) £8 million for systems and controls failures that enabled four employees to carry out unauthorised transactions involving customer money on at least 39 accounts.
The unauthorised activity, which took place between January 2006 and December 2007 at UBS’ London-based wealth management business, only came to light when a whistleblower raised concerns internally. Upon further investigation, it was discovered that UBS employees had taken part in the trading of foreign exchange and precious metals using customer money without authorisation and allocated losses to customers’ accounts. An internal UBS investigation estimated that as many as 50 unauthorised transactions a day were taking place at the operation’s peak.
The FSA investigation found that UBS had failed to: manage and control the key risks, and the level of risk, created by its international wealth management business model; implement effective remedial measures in response to several warning signs that suggested the business’ systems and controls were inadequate; and provide an appropriate level of supervision over customer-facing employees. Margaret Cole, FSA director of enforcement and financial crime, said: “The penalty, one of the largest fines we have levied, reflects our tougher enforcement stance and our policy of imposing steep penalties to achieve credible deterrence.
“These employees were able to take advantage of UBS’ inadequate systems and controls, giving them free rein to make unauthorised trades with customer money that they were then able to conceal.
“It is imperative, particularly in these more challenging financial conditions, that firms have suitable systems and controls in place to keep their houses in order. Where firms fall short in this regard, the consequences will be severe.” The £8 million fine is the third largest the FSA has ever imposed. UBS agreed to settle at an early stage of the FSA’s investigation meaning it qualified for a 20% discount. Without the discount, the FSA would have imposed a financial penalty of £10 million. UBS has since paid compensation in excess of US$42 million by way of redress for its customers’ losses.
So the FSA crackdown continues.
Although what is even more astonishing to us is that £8m is the third-largest ever fine imposed by the FSA.
Surely that’s small chips to even the most distressed institutional banks?
Related link:
Chinese takeout: FSA insider trading crackdown continues - FT Alphaville